McLetchie-Holder Shelley, Showunmi Victoria, Bragg Sara
Faculty of Nursing, Midwifery & Palliative Care, King's College London, 57 Waterloo Road, London, SE1 8WA, United Kingdom.
Faculty of Education and Society, University College London, 20 Bedford Way, London, WCH 0AL, United Kingdom.
Nurse Educ Today. 2025 Mar;146:106552. doi: 10.1016/j.nedt.2024.106552. Epub 2024 Dec 21.
Personal tutoring at university is designed to provide effective pastoral care to students. Given the increasing diversity of the student body, it is important that personal tutors can support the needs of all students. There is limited research to date which has focused on the personal tutoring needs of Black nursing students.
To understand Black nursing students' perceptions and experiences of receiving personal tutor support at university and identify factors which hinder and facilitate the provision of effective personal tutoring to Black nursing students.
An exploratory qualitative study using a phenomenological approach.
A nursing and midwifery faculty within a large urban university in the United Kingdom.
Black nursing students and personal tutors with experience of supporting Black nursing students.
Data were collected through individual in-depth interviews and were analysed using thematic analysis.
Although some student participants reported positive experiences, others undergoing family difficulties or having academic issues were disappointed with the support provided by their tutor. Four main themes were developed from the data: 1) Insufficient support from personal tutor: "I could have had more help"; 2) Cultural Competency: "Just get to know us"; 3) Sense of belonging: "No one looks like me" and 4) Resilience: "And still I rise."
Black nursing students face many challenges at university as a minoritised group and value a supportive and emotional connection with their tutors. Personal tutors want institutions to provide them with more time and specialised training to provide appropriate support to students from different cultural backgrounds.
大学中的个人辅导旨在为学生提供有效的人文关怀。鉴于学生群体日益多样化,个人导师能够满足所有学生的需求非常重要。迄今为止,针对黑人护理专业学生个人辅导需求的研究有限。
了解黑人护理专业学生在大学接受个人导师支持的看法和经历,并确定阻碍和促进为黑人护理专业学生提供有效个人辅导的因素。
采用现象学方法的探索性定性研究。
英国一所大型城市大学的护理与助产学院。
有支持黑人护理专业学生经验的黑人护理专业学生和个人导师。
通过个人深度访谈收集数据,并使用主题分析法进行分析。
尽管一些学生参与者报告了积极的经历,但其他经历家庭困难或有学业问题的学生对导师提供的支持感到失望。从数据中提炼出四个主要主题:1)个人导师支持不足:“我本可以得到更多帮助”;2)文化能力:“了解我们”;3)归属感:“没有人像我”;4)复原力:“我依然崛起”。
作为少数群体,黑人护理专业学生在大学面临许多挑战,他们重视与导师的支持性情感联系。个人导师希望机构为他们提供更多时间和专业培训,以便为来自不同文化背景的学生提供适当支持。