Gould Harriet L, Amin Kapish, Karategos Thanos, Abbas Sarah, Olive Susannah, Sivananthan Mathoorika, Rela Ayeesha, Reed Harriet, Powell Catherine, Navaratnam Janu, Ellis-Owen Rwth, Fielding Patrick, Mondal Dipanjali, Kihara Steve, Williams Gethin, Morgan Carys, Witczak Justyna, Cornish Julie, Gwynne Sarah, Horwood James, Torkington Jared, Hargest Rachel, Christian Adam, Davies Michael, Ansell James, Khan Mohid S
Cardiff University, Cardiff, UK.
South Wales Neuroendocrine Tumour Service, Department of Gastroenterology, Cardiff and Vale University Health Board, Cardiff, UK.
J Neuroendocrinol. 2025 Apr;37(4):e13486. doi: 10.1111/jne.13486. Epub 2024 Dec 26.
Small intestine neuroendocrine tumours (SI-NETs) are often diagnosed late with a UK median of 3 years and high misdiagnosis rates. Previous studies, largely based on patient surveys, offer little data on improving diagnosis. In 2017, the South Wales NET service underwent a nationally commissioned, systematic transformation, aiming to improve diagnosis through the development of a gastroenterology and surgical referral network, and education of these specialities. This study aims to assess the impact of the transformation on SI-NET diagnosis times and misdiagnosis rates using accurate hospital data, along with the diagnostic routes and investigations used for SI-NETs. We retrospectively analysed the hospital records of 224 patients diagnosed with SI-NETs referred to the South Wales NET service (110 pre-transformation and 114 post-transformation). Following the service transformation, there was a significant reduction in diagnosis times from a median of 12.5-5.2 months (p < .05), at an earlier stage (cases with metastases reduced from 77% to 62%), and reduced misdiagnosis rates from 40% to 25%. Colonoscopy, used to investigate the presenting gastrointestinal symptoms in 42% of patients prior to diagnosis, identified an abnormality in only 28%, compared with 97% with computed tomography (CT) scans. A gastroenterology and surgical referral network across hospitals may improve diagnosis in SI-NETs, leading to earlier detection and reducing misdiagnosis rates. Further exploration of GP interactions is needed. Caution is needed following negative colonoscopy in patients with persistent lower gastrointestinal symptoms as this could lead to missed SI-NET diagnosis if further abdominal imaging is not undertaken.
小肠神经内分泌肿瘤(SI-NETs)常常在晚期才被诊断出来,在英国,其中位诊断时间为3年,误诊率很高。以前的研究主要基于患者调查,提供的关于改善诊断的数据很少。2017年,南威尔士神经内分泌肿瘤服务进行了一项由国家委托的系统性变革,旨在通过建立胃肠病学和外科转诊网络以及对这些专业进行培训来改善诊断。本研究旨在利用准确的医院数据评估这一变革对SI-NET诊断时间和误诊率的影响,以及SI-NETs的诊断途径和所采用的检查方法。我们回顾性分析了224例被诊断为SI-NETs并转诊至南威尔士神经内分泌肿瘤服务的患者的医院记录(变革前110例,变革后114例)。服务变革后,诊断时间显著缩短,从12.5个月的中位数降至5.2个月(p < 0.05),且诊断阶段更早(有转移的病例从77%降至62%),误诊率从40%降至25%。在诊断前,42%的患者接受结肠镜检查以调查出现的胃肠道症状,其中仅28%发现异常,而计算机断层扫描(CT)扫描的发现异常率为97%。跨医院的胃肠病学和外科转诊网络可能会改善SI-NETs的诊断,从而实现更早发现并降低误诊率。需要进一步探索全科医生的互动情况。对于持续存在下消化道症状的患者,结肠镜检查结果为阴性后需谨慎,因为如果不进行进一步的腹部影像学检查,可能会导致SI-NET诊断遗漏。