Ford Andrea L B, Elmquist Marianne, Johnson LeAnne D, Tapp Jon
Department of Communication Sciences and Disorders, University of Cincinnati, OH.
Waisman Center, University of Wisconsin-Madison.
J Speech Lang Hear Res. 2025 Jan 2;68(1):248-258. doi: 10.1044/2024_JSLHR-24-00195. Epub 2024 Dec 12.
Estimating the sequential associations between educators' and children's talk during language learning interactions requires careful consideration of factors that may impact measurement stability and resultant inferences. This research note will describe a preliminary study that used generalizability theory to understand the contribution of two measurement conditions- and -on estimates of sequential associations between educator talk and autistic preschooler talk in inclusive preschool classrooms.
We used an existing data set of four 15-min video-recorded occasions of educator-child interactions for 11 autistic preschoolers during free-play in their inclusive classroom. Two trained raters coded all videos for preschooler talk and type of educator talk (i.e., opportunities for expressive language [OELs], other talk). We conducted two generalizability studies on sequential association estimates for two interaction directions (i.e., preschooler talk following educator OEL and educator talk following preschooler talk). We conducted a series of decision studies to explore configurations of measurement conditions to optimize future investigations.
We had unstable estimates for both interaction directions in our current methodological approach, with raters accounting for minimal error and occasions accounting for considerable error. Future investigations would require at least six observation occasions for stable estimates of the sequential association between autistic preschooler talk following educator OEL that was stable after six occasions. More than 15 occasions were required for stable estimates of the association between educator talk following autistic preschooler talk.
We will share recommendations and implications for future investigations to estimate educator and child talk sequential associations within preschool language interactions.
在语言学习互动过程中评估教育者与儿童言语之间的序列关联,需要仔细考虑可能影响测量稳定性及最终推断结果的因素。本研究报告将描述一项初步研究,该研究运用概化理论来理解两种测量条件对全纳性学前班教室中教育者言语与自闭症学龄前儿童言语之间序列关联估计值的影响。
我们使用了一个现有数据集,该数据集包含11名自闭症学龄前儿童在其全纳性教室自由玩耍期间的4次时长15分钟的教育者-儿童互动视频记录。两名经过培训的评分者对所有视频中儿童的言语以及教育者言语的类型(即表达性语言机会[OELs]、其他言语)进行编码。我们针对两个互动方向(即教育者OEL之后的儿童言语以及儿童言语之后的教育者言语)的序列关联估计值进行了两项概化研究。我们开展了一系列决策研究,以探索测量条件的配置,从而优化未来的调查。
在我们当前的方法中,两个互动方向的估计值都不稳定,评分者造成的误差最小,而观察场合造成的误差相当大。未来的调查至少需要六个观察场合,才能对教育者OEL之后的自闭症学龄前儿童言语之间的序列关联进行稳定估计,六个场合之后该关联是稳定的。对于自闭症学龄前儿童言语之后的教育者言语之间的关联进行稳定估计,则需要超过15个场合。
我们将分享对未来调查的建议及启示,以便在学前语言互动中评估教育者与儿童言语的序列关联。