Giraldo Juan P, Cho Steve S, Eghrari Nafis B, Dholaria Nikhil, Farber S Harrison, Ehredt Ryan B, Michaels Chinami, Fotias Demos J, Godzik Jakub, Sonntag Volker K H, Uribe Juan S
1Department of Neurosurgery, Barrow Neurological Institute, St. Joseph's Hospital and Medical Center, Phoenix, Arizona; and.
2Department of Neurological Surgery, University of Alabama at Birmingham, Alabama.
J Neurosurg Spine. 2025 Jan 3;42(3):385-398. doi: 10.3171/2024.8.SPINE24237. Print 2025 Mar 1.
Mixed-reality (MR) applications provide opportunities for technical rehearsal, education, and estimation of surgical performance without the risk of patient harm. In this study, the authors provide a structured literature review on the current state of MR applications and their effects on neurosurgery training. They also introduce an MR prototype for neurosurgical spine training.
An extensive review of the literature based on MR, education, and neurosurgery was performed using the MEDLINE, Cochrane, Scopus, and Embase databases from January 1, 2013, to October 5, 2023. The terms used for the search included "augmented reality," "mixed reality," "education," "neurosurgery," and "neurosurgical procedures." After evaluating the results in the literature, the authors designed an MR prototype to investigate the use of 3D models, haptic feedback, and virtual reality (VR) in an educational module for freehand pedicle screw placement training.
Of the 1089 articles found in the databases, 111 duplicate articles were removed, and 978 articles were screened for MR and neurosurgery. Forty articles were selected to explore the relationship between MR environments and neurosurgery. Of these, 25 described cranial MR use, 13 described spine MR use, and 2 described cranial and spine MR training and education modules. The structured review exposed the relationships between MR environments in neurosurgical education, procedures, functional outcomes, novel technologies, and medical training limitations. These studies revealed favorable feedback for MR modules in neurosurgical education, training, and surgical operative outcomes, warranting further investigation to compare MR-based complementary curriculums, standard training methods, and the underlying advantages and disadvantages of MR modules for neurosurgical pedagogy. Based on this literature review, the authors developed an early MR prototype using a 3D model of scoliosis, a surgical tool tracking system, and conductive material for freehand pedicle screw placement.
The technological features, cost-effectiveness, and limitations of MR are currently being adapted to complement education, surgical optimization, and forecasting applications in neurosurgery. An MR surgical spine prototype was developed as a complementary educational tool.
混合现实(MR)应用为技术演练、教育以及评估手术操作提供了机会,且不存在伤害患者的风险。在本研究中,作者对MR应用的现状及其对神经外科培训的影响进行了结构化文献综述。他们还介绍了一种用于神经外科脊柱培训的MR原型。
使用MEDLINE、Cochrane、Scopus和Embase数据库,对2013年1月1日至2023年10月5日期间基于MR、教育和神经外科的文献进行了广泛综述。搜索所用术语包括“增强现实”“混合现实”“教育”“神经外科”和“神经外科手术”。在评估文献结果后,作者设计了一个MR原型,以研究三维模型、触觉反馈和虚拟现实(VR)在徒手椎弓根螺钉置入训练教育模块中的应用。
在数据库中找到的1089篇文章中,去除了111篇重复文章,对978篇文章进行了MR和神经外科方面的筛选。选择了40篇文章来探讨MR环境与神经外科之间的关系。其中,25篇描述了颅脑MR的应用,13篇描述了脊柱MR的应用,2篇描述了颅脑和脊柱MR培训及教育模块。结构化综述揭示了神经外科教育、手术、功能结果、新技术和医学培训局限性中MR环境之间的关系。这些研究显示出对神经外科教育、培训和手术操作结果中MR模块的良好反馈,有必要进一步研究以比较基于MR的补充课程、标准培训方法以及MR模块在神经外科教学中的潜在优缺点。基于此文献综述,作者使用脊柱侧弯三维模型、手术工具跟踪系统和用于徒手椎弓根螺钉置入的导电材料开发了一个早期MR原型。
目前正在对MR的技术特性、成本效益和局限性进行调整,以补充神经外科的教育、手术优化和预测应用。开发了一个MR手术脊柱原型作为补充教育工具。