Brites Luisa, Cunha Rita, Santos Helena, Donato Helena, Pimentel-Santos Fernando
Unidade Local de Saúde - Região de Leiria.
Unidade Local de Saúde do Baixo Vouga.
ARP Rheumatol. 2024 Oct-Dec;3(4):310-319. doi: 10.63032/DIBS9955.
The current standard of care of patients with spondyloarthritis (SpA), in addition to pharmacological treatment, includes regular exercise and patient education.(1) The primary goal of this systematic literature review (SLR) is to update the evidence of the effectiveness of education programs for patients with axial SpA (axSpA).
We systematically searched three databases, PubMed, Embase and Web of Science Core Collection, from January 2000 to June 2023, using the following terms: "patient education", "patient counselling", "patient teaching", "patient engaging", "patient empowerment", "health education", "spondyloarthritis", "spondyloarthropaties", "spondylitis" and "ankylosing spondylitis". The "Population (P)", "Intervention (I)", "Comparator (C)", "Outcome (O)", PICO criteria were used. "P", defined as axSpA, "I" as education, "C" as standard of care or physical exercise and "O" as disease activity, Bath Ankylosing Spondylitis Disease Activity Index (BASDAI), Ankylosing Spondylitis Disease Activity Score (ASDAS); disease functional repercussion, Bath Ankylosing Spondylitis Functional Index (BASFI); disease metrological repercussion, Bath Ankylosing Spondylitis Metrological Index (BASMI); disease quality of life Ankylosing Spondylitis Quality of Life (ASQoL), EuroQol-5D (EQ-5D) and Short Form 36 Health Survey (SF36); disease economic impact, cost-utility, cost-benefit and incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER). Only randomized clinical trials were included. Two reviewers independently assessed the identified papers according to the established criteria and extracted the data.
From the initial 494 studies identified, 6 were selected for data extraction and qualitative analysis. The study sample sizes ranged between 41-65 individuals, all diagnosed with ankylosing spondylitis. The leaders of the programs varied, the intervention period ranged between 4-12 weeks and the follow up ranged between 3-12 months. In three studies, the comparator was standard of care, and in the other three was physical exercise. Overall, there was an improvement in BASDAI, BASFI, BASMI, ASQoL and SF-36, after the application of educational programs. No studies evaluated the economic impact of educational programs.
Education appears to be an important adjuvant as non-pharmacological treatment for patients with axSpA, enhancing various disease outcomes, particularly when delivered by Health Professionals using physical materials such as pamphlets. However, there is an ongoing need for additional research to obtain more robust conclusions.
除药物治疗外,目前脊柱关节炎(SpA)患者的标准治疗还包括定期锻炼和患者教育。(1)本系统文献综述(SLR)的主要目的是更新针对中轴型SpA(axSpA)患者教育项目有效性的证据。
我们于2000年1月至2023年6月,系统检索了三个数据库,即PubMed、Embase和Web of Science核心合集,使用了以下检索词:“患者教育”、“患者咨询”、“患者教学”、“患者参与”、“患者赋权”、“健康教育”、“脊柱关节炎”、“脊柱关节病”、“脊柱炎”和“强直性脊柱炎”。采用了“人群(P)”、“干预(I)”、“对照(C)”、“结局(O)”的PICO标准。“P”定义为axSpA,“I”为教育,“C”为标准治疗或体育锻炼,“O”为疾病活动度、巴斯强直性脊柱炎疾病活动指数(BASDAI)、强直性脊柱炎疾病活动评分(ASDAS);疾病功能影响,巴斯强直性脊柱炎功能指数(BASFI);疾病计量学影响,巴斯强直性脊柱炎计量学指数(BASMI);疾病生活质量,强直性脊柱炎生活质量(ASQoL)、欧洲五维健康量表(EQ - 5D)和简明健康调查问卷(SF36);疾病经济影响、成本效益、成本效益分析和增量成本效益比(ICER)。仅纳入随机临床试验。两名评审员根据既定标准独立评估所识别的论文并提取数据。
从最初识别出的494项研究中,选取了6项进行数据提取和定性分析。研究样本量在41 - 65人之间,均诊断为强直性脊柱炎。项目负责人各不相同,干预期在4 - 12周之间,随访期在3 - 12个月之间。在三项研究中,对照为标准治疗,在另外三项中为体育锻炼。总体而言,实施教育项目后,BASDAI、BASFI、BASMI、ASQoL和SF - 36均有改善。没有研究评估教育项目的经济影响。
教育似乎是axSpA患者非药物治疗的重要辅助手段,可改善多种疾病结局,特别是由健康专业人员使用宣传册等实物材料进行教育时。然而,仍需要更多研究以得出更有力的结论。