Morey Jacob, Schupbach John, Jones Derick, Walker Laura, Lindor Rachel, Loufek Brenna, Mullan Aidan, Cabrera Daniel
Department of Emergency Medicine, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, MN, USA.
Department of Emergency Medicine, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, MN, USA.
Am J Emerg Med. 2025 Mar;89:241-246. doi: 10.1016/j.ajem.2024.12.062. Epub 2024 Dec 25.
To identify and assess artificial intelligence (AI)-enabled products reviewed by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) that are potentially applicable to emergency medicine (EM).
The FDA AI-enabled products website was accessed to identify all marketed products as of March 2024. Board-certified EM physicians analyzed all products for applicability to EM practice. Inclusion criteria included products used by EM physicians directly or non-EM physicians participating directly in the evaluation and management of patients in an acute care setting. The Clinical and Economic Review (ICER) Evidence Rating Matrix was used to rate the net health benefit of applicable products.
A total of 882 AI-enabled products have been reviewed by the FDA from 1995 to 2024. There were 272 products that were updates of prior products that were excluded, leaving 610 unique products. Products were most commonly evaluated by Radiology (454/610), Cardiovascular (59/610), and Neurology (25/610) panels. We found 154 (25 %) products applicable to EM that were approved through Radiology (121/154), Cardiovascular (24/154), Neurology (5/154), Anesthesiology (3/154), and Ophthalmology (1/154) panels. There were 30 products that were rated as having a comparable or incremental net health benefit with moderate certainty (a C+ rating).
An increasing number of AI-enabled products are available and regulated by the FDA. We have identified 154 that are applicable to EM, primarily related to assisting with diagnosis on various imaging modalities. There remain many opportunities for EM to assist in product reviews and meaningful translation of products into clinical practice.
识别并评估美国食品药品监督管理局(FDA)审查的、可能适用于急诊医学(EM)的人工智能(AI)产品。
访问FDA的人工智能产品网站,以识别截至2024年3月的所有已上市产品。具有董事会认证的急诊医学医生分析所有产品对急诊医学实践的适用性。纳入标准包括急诊医学医生直接使用的产品,或直接参与急性护理环境中患者评估和管理的非急诊医学医生使用的产品。使用临床和经济审查(ICER)证据评级矩阵对适用产品的净健康效益进行评级。
1995年至2024年,FDA共审查了882种人工智能产品。有272种产品是先前产品的更新版本,已被排除,剩下610种独特产品。产品最常由放射学(454/610)、心血管(59/610)和神经学(25/610)小组评估。我们发现154种(25%)适用于急诊医学的产品通过放射学(121/154)、心血管(24/154)、神经学(5/154)、麻醉学(3/154)和眼科(1/154)小组获得批准。有30种产品被评为具有相当或增加的净健康效益,且具有中等确定性(C+评级)。
越来越多的人工智能产品可供使用,并受到FDA监管。我们已经识别出154种适用于急诊医学的产品,主要与辅助各种成像模式的诊断有关。急诊医学在协助产品审查以及将产品有意义地转化为临床实践方面仍有许多机会。