Preovolos Christos, Grant Abby, Rayner Morgan, Fitzgerald Kylie, Ng Louisa
Melbourne Medical School, The University of Melbourne, Melbourne, Australia.
Department of Rehabilitation Medicine, The Royal Melbourne Hospital, Melbourne, Australia.
Med Sci Educ. 2024 Jul 4;34(6):1577-1602. doi: 10.1007/s40670-024-02108-7. eCollection 2024 Dec.
Medical school transitions pose challenges for students. Mentoring programs may aid students, but evidence supporting peer/near-peer mentoring in medical school is unclear. Our review explores peer mentoring's benefits, elements for success and challenges. Searches in major databases yielded 1676 records, resulting in 20 eligible studies involving 4591 participants. Longitudinal ( = 15) and shorter, focused programs were examined. Mentors and mentees reported psychosocial, professional and academic benefits. Essential elements included matching, orientation and clear goals, with training crucial yet balanced to avoid mentor overload. Social congruence underpinned successful peer mentoring, particularly benefiting under-represented groups. Challenges include balancing mentor load and logistics.
医学院过渡阶段给学生带来了挑战。指导计划可能会帮助学生,但支持医学院同伴/近同伴指导的证据尚不清楚。我们的综述探讨了同伴指导的益处、成功要素和挑战。在主要数据库中进行检索得到了1676条记录,最终有20项符合条件的研究,涉及4591名参与者。研究考察了纵向(n = 15)和较短的、重点突出的项目。导师和学员都报告了心理社会、专业和学业方面的益处。基本要素包括匹配、培训指导和明确目标,培训很关键,但要保持平衡以避免导师负担过重。社会一致性是成功的同伴指导的基础,尤其使代表性不足的群体受益。挑战包括平衡导师负担和后勤保障。