Farrow P R, Jones D A, Stanley P J, Bailey J S, Wales J M, Cookson J B
Thorax. 1985 Feb;40(2):121-4. doi: 10.1136/thx.40.2.121.
Although the incidence of superficial glandular tuberculosis is high in Asian immigrants, a clinical diagnosis without biopsy has previously been shown to be inaccurate in 22% of cases. The role of diagnostic mediastinoscopy and biopsy in thoracic lymphadenopathy was therefore evaluated in 41 consecutive Asian patients. Tuberculosis was diagnosed by histological examination or culture (or both) of gland biopsy material in 24 (59%). A further 12 patients, however, also received antituberculous chemotherapy, with a response in 10 cases. If these are included, 34 (83%) were finally considered to have tuberculosis. The symptoms and ages of the patients with tuberculosis were similar to those typically seen in caucasians with sarcoidosis. Six had tuberculous bilateral hilar lymphadenopathy. In only four cases (10%) was a positive diagnosis other than tuberculosis established; in two (lymphoma and thymoma) mediastinoscopy confirmed preoperative suspicions, and saved only two more (with sarcoidosis and vascular anomaly) from unnecessary antituberculous treatment. Complications included severe haemorrhage (1) and chronic tuberculous sinus in the endoscopy tract (2). Mediastinoscopy is unlikely to change management in most patients, produces an appreciable amount of morbidity, and should be reserved for cases in which there is additional clinical doubt. Any future decline in the prevalence of tuberculosis in Asians may, however, require its further evaluation.
尽管浅表腺结核在亚洲移民中的发病率很高,但先前研究表明,在22%的病例中,未经活检的临床诊断并不准确。因此,对41例连续的亚洲患者评估了诊断性纵隔镜检查及活检在胸段淋巴结病中的作用。通过对腺活检材料进行组织学检查或培养(或两者皆做),确诊24例(59%)为结核病。然而,另有12例患者也接受了抗结核化疗,其中10例有反应。若将这些患者包括在内,最终34例(83%)被认为患有结核病。结核病患者的症状和年龄与白种人结节病患者的典型表现相似。6例有双侧肺门结核性淋巴结病。仅4例(10%)确诊为非结核性疾病;其中2例(淋巴瘤和胸腺瘤)纵隔镜检查证实了术前怀疑,另外仅2例(结节病和血管异常)避免了不必要的抗结核治疗。并发症包括严重出血(1例)和内镜通道慢性结核性窦道(2例)。纵隔镜检查在大多数患者中不太可能改变治疗方案,会产生相当数量的发病率,应仅用于存在额外临床疑问的病例。然而,未来亚洲人结核病患病率的任何下降可能都需要对其进行进一步评估。