Basuodan Reem M
Department of Rehabilitation Sciences, College of Health and Rehabilitation Sciences, Princess Nourah bint Abdulrahman University, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia.
Adv Med Educ Pract. 2024 Dec 30;15:1339-1347. doi: 10.2147/AMEP.S493782. eCollection 2024.
The learning methods employed in medical education have substantially transformed from traditional face-to-face (FTF) instruction to online learning modalities. This study sought to quantitatively compare the impact of three learning methods on the academic performance of first-year medical and health sciences students enrolled in a Medical Terminology (MT) course. The learning methods examined include the FTF method, the online-synchronized method, and a blended learning method that combines elements of both. The scope of the analysis encompasses the academic years 2019, 2020, and 2023.
Academic performance was measured using overall scores and scores derived from the letter grades of 2446 first-year students assigned to the three learning methods that were compared.
A significant improvement in 2023 was observed in the blended learning method, which consisted of 30% FTF and 70% online synchronized lectures for overall scores (p < 0.0) and the scores based on the A grades (p < 0.0) of students in the MT course, compared to the FTF learning method in 2019 or the online synchronized learning method in 2020.
The blended learning method, which combines FTF with online synchronized learning, appears to be a more effective method for enhancing the academic performance of first-year students compared to either the traditional FTF method or the solely online synchronized method.
医学教育中采用的学习方法已从传统的面对面(FTF)教学大幅转变为在线学习模式。本研究旨在定量比较三种学习方法对参加医学术语(MT)课程的一年级医学和健康科学专业学生学业成绩的影响。所考察的学习方法包括面对面教学法、在线同步教学法以及将两者要素结合的混合学习法。分析范围涵盖2019年、2020年和2023学年。
使用总体成绩以及分配到三种被比较学习方法的2446名一年级学生的字母等级成绩来衡量学业成绩。
与2019年的面对面学习法或2020年的在线同步学习法相比,2023年观察到混合学习法有显著进步,该混合学习法由30%的面对面教学和70%的在线同步讲座组成,在MT课程学生的总体成绩(p < 0.0)和基于A等级的成绩(p < 0.0)方面均有体现。
与传统的面对面教学法或单纯的在线同步教学法相比,将面对面教学与在线同步学习相结合的混合学习法似乎是提高一年级学生学业成绩的更有效方法。