Ramirez Mauricio Marco Aurelio, Berton Marco, Amalfitano Nicolò, Giannuzzi Diana, Pegolo Sara, Raniolo Salvatore, Nocetti Marco, Negrini Riccardo, Coppa Mauro, Martin Bruno, Schiavon Stefano, Gallo Luigi, Sturaro Enrico, Cecchinato Alessio
Department of Agronomy, Food, Natural Resources, Animals and Environment (DAFNAE), University of Padova, 35020, Legnaro (PD), Italy.
Department of Agronomy, Food, Natural Resources, Animals and Environment (DAFNAE), University of Padova, 35020, Legnaro (PD), Italy.
J Dairy Sci. 2025 Mar;108(3):2642-2657. doi: 10.3168/jds.2024-25466. Epub 2025 Jan 6.
Increasing consumer concerns underscore the importance of verifying the practices and origins of food, especially certified premium products. The aim of this study was to evaluate the ability of Fourier-transform mid-infrared (FT-MIR) spectroscopy to authenticate animal welfare parameters, farming practices, and dairy systems. Data on farm characteristics were obtained from the Parmigiano Reggiano Consortium in northern Italy. Animal welfare data were collected by trained veterinarians using the assessment protocol developed by the Italian National Reference Center for Animal Welfare (CReNBA), and bulk milk test-day data were obtained from the laboratory of the Breeders Association of the Emilia Romagna Region. A merged final dataset of 12,083 bulk FT-MIR spectra records from 949 farms was created. Using a nonhierarchical clustering approach, the farms were classified into 5 dairy systems: 2 traditional systems comprising farms located in either the Apennines or the Po Plain; 2 modern systems, one that used TMR and one did not; and one traditional dairy system comprising farms rearing local breeds. To evaluate the ability of bulk milk to capture differences in farming systems, we conducted an ANOVA on milk composition. The linear models included the following effects: season, dairy system, farm, and the interaction between dairy system and season. The effect of the dairy system was significant for all milk composition traits. A 10-iteration linear discriminant analysis was used to evaluate the discriminative ability of the spectra in classifying farming practices and dairy systems. The average results of the area under the receiver operating characteristic curve revealed good authentication performance for genetic type (0.98), housing system (0.91), and feeding system (0.89), and medium-low authentication performance for geographical area (0.70); poor results were obtained for the percentage of concentrate in the diet and animal welfare parameters (0.57-0.64). With regard to dairy systems, the best result was obtained when dairy systems were grouped into 2 simplified categories, traditional versus modern (0.89), instead of the 5 categories (0.87). The results of this study show that FT-MIR is a useful tool for authenticating farming practices and dairy systems, but not animal welfare as defined by CReNBA evaluation criteria. Our results show that infrared spectroscopy has the potential to authenticate dairy products and quality label certifications.
消费者日益增长的担忧凸显了核实食品生产方式和产地的重要性,尤其是经过认证的优质产品。本研究的目的是评估傅里叶变换中红外(FT-MIR)光谱法对动物福利参数、养殖方式和乳制品系统进行认证的能力。农场特征数据来自意大利北部的帕尔马干酪联盟。动物福利数据由经过培训的兽医使用意大利国家动物福利参考中心(CReNBA)制定的评估方案收集,批量牛奶检测日数据则来自艾米利亚-罗马涅地区养殖者协会的实验室。创建了一个合并后的最终数据集,包含来自949个农场的12,083条批量FT-MIR光谱记录。采用非层次聚类方法,将农场分为5种乳制品系统:2种传统系统,包括位于亚平宁山脉或波河平原的农场;2种现代系统,一种使用全混合日粮(TMR),另一种不使用;以及一种传统乳制品系统,包括饲养当地品种的农场。为了评估批量牛奶捕捉养殖系统差异的能力,我们对牛奶成分进行了方差分析。线性模型包括以下效应:季节、乳制品系统、农场以及乳制品系统与季节之间的相互作用。乳制品系统对所有牛奶成分特征的影响均显著。使用10次迭代的线性判别分析来评估光谱在区分养殖方式和乳制品系统方面的判别能力。接收器操作特征曲线下面积的平均结果显示,遗传类型(0.98)、饲养系统(0.91)和饲喂系统(0.89)的认证性能良好,地理区域(0.70)的认证性能为中低水平;日粮中精饲料百分比和动物福利参数的结果较差(0.57 - 0.64)。关于乳制品系统,当将乳制品系统分为传统与现代这2个简化类别时,得到的最佳结果(0.89),而非5个类别时的结果(0.87)。本研究结果表明,FT-MIR是验证养殖方式和乳制品系统的有用工具,但无法按照CReNBA评估标准验证动物福利。我们的结果表明,红外光谱法有潜力验证乳制品和质量标签认证。