van Zyl C L, Eriksson H K, Bokkers E A M, Kemp B, van Knegsel A T M, Agenäs S
Adaptation Physiology group, Wageningen University & Research, 6700 AH Wageningen, the Netherlands; Animal Production Systems group, Wageningen University & Research, 6700 AH Wageningen, the Netherlands.
Department of Applied Animal Science and Welfare, Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences, 750 07 Uppsala, Sweden.
J Dairy Sci. 2025 Mar;108(3):2820-2838. doi: 10.3168/jds.2024-25202. Epub 2025 Jan 7.
In cow-calf contact (CCC) systems breaking the maternal bond may induce stress for the cow, thereby affecting feed intake, milk yield, milk flow rate, and milk electrical conductivity. This study aimed to determine the consequences of weaning and separation strategies in CCC systems for feed intake and milking characteristics of the cow. In 2 experiments, Swedish Holstein and Swedish Red cows either had (experiment 1) whole-day CCC (CCC1, n = 12) for 8.5 ± 1.2 wk (mean ± SD) followed by 12 h of daytime CCC for 8 wk, before abrupt weaning and separation at 16.4 ± 1.2 wk, or (experiment 2) whole-day CCC for 16 ± 1.0 wk; thereafter half of the calves were weaned via nose flaps for 2 wk (NF, n = 10) before physical separation and half via nose flaps for 1 wk and fence-line contact for 1 wk (NFFL, n = 9). Cows were compared with conventionally managed cows (CONV1 or CONV2 in experiment 1 or 2) separated from their calves within 12 h postpartum. In experiment 1, the study period included the week before and after the system switch from whole-day to daytime CCC, and the week before and after separation. In experiment 2, the study period included the week before the start of weaning, during weaning, and 1 week after separation. All cows were milked in the same automatic milking unit. In experiment 1, feed intake of CCC1 cows at separation tended to be lower than CONV1 cows. In experiment 2, roughage intake of NF, NFFL, and CONV2 cows did not differ, but the concentrate intake of NF cows was lower than that of CONV2 cows. In experiment 1, the system switch did not affect milking characteristics. However, after separation, machine milk yield and milk electrical conductivity of CCC1 cows increased, remaining lower than CONV1 cows. In experiment 2, machine milk yield of NF and NFFL cows increased when calves were fitted with nose flaps, but remained lower than CONV2 cows. In the week after separation, milk yield of NFFL cows was similar to that of CONV2 cows, and the NF cows remained lower. In the week before weaning, milk flow rates of NF cows were lower than those of CONV2 cows, and the NFFL cows did not differ. Before weaning, milk electrical conductivity of NF and NFFL cows was lower than that of CONV2 cows, but not thereafter. In conclusion, machine milk yield of CCC cows remained lower either until the week of separation, for NFFL cows, or until 3 or 11 wk after weaning and separation for CCC1 and NF cows of experiments 1 and 2, respectively. Cow-calf contact reduced milk electrical conductivity, and milk and peak milk flow rates increased the week after separation of cow and calf. Not for experiment 2, but for experiment 1, cow roughage and concentrate intake decreased at separation and recovered within a week, indicating that abrupt separation exerted a greater impact on the cow than separation after nose flap weaning or fence-line contact. Future studies should compare both weaning strategies within the same experimental setup, also focusing on the consequences for calves.
在母牛 - 犊牛接触(CCC)系统中,打破母婴联系可能会给母牛带来压力,从而影响采食量、产奶量、乳汁流速和乳汁电导率。本研究旨在确定CCC系统中的断奶和分离策略对母牛采食量和挤奶特性的影响。在2项实验中,瑞典荷斯坦奶牛和瑞典红牛要么(实验1)在8.5±1.2周(均值±标准差)内进行全天CCC(CCC1,n = 12),随后在8周内进行12小时的白天CCC,然后在16.4±1.2周时突然断奶并分离,要么(实验2)进行16±1.0周的全天CCC;此后,一半的犊牛通过鼻瓣断奶2周(NF,n = 10),然后进行物理分离,另一半通过鼻瓣断奶1周并进行1周的围栏接触(NFFL,n = 9)。将这些母牛与产后12小时内与其犊牛分离的传统管理母牛(实验1或2中的CONV1或CONV2)进行比较。在实验1中,研究期包括从全天CCC切换到白天CCC之前和之后的一周,以及分离之前和之后的一周。在实验2中,研究期包括断奶开始前的一周、断奶期间以及分离后的一周。所有母牛都在同一自动挤奶单元中挤奶。在实验1中,分离时CCC1母牛的采食量往往低于CONV1母牛。在实验2中,NF、NFFL和CONV2母牛的粗饲料采食量没有差异,但NF母牛的精饲料采食量低于CONV2母牛。在实验1中,系统切换不影响挤奶特性。然而,分离后,CCC1母牛的机械产奶量和乳汁电导率增加,但仍低于CONV1母牛。在实验2中,当给犊牛安装鼻瓣时,NF和NFFL母牛的机械产奶量增加,但仍低于CONV2母牛。在分离后的一周内,NFFL母牛的产奶量与CONV2母牛相似,而NF母牛的产奶量仍然较低。在断奶前的一周,NF母牛的乳汁流速低于CONV2母牛,而NFFL母牛没有差异。断奶前,NF和NFFL母牛的乳汁电导率低于CONV2母牛,但断奶后则不然。总之,CCC母牛的机械产奶量在分离周之前(对于NFFL母牛)或分别在实验1和2的CCC1和NF母牛断奶和分离后3周或11周之前一直较低。母牛 - 犊牛接触降低了乳汁电导率,并且在母牛和犊牛分离后的一周内,乳汁和峰值乳汁流速增加。不是对于实验2,而是对于实验1,母牛的粗饲料和精饲料采食量在分离时下降,并在一周内恢复,这表明突然分离对母牛的影响比对鼻瓣断奶或围栏接触后分离的影响更大。未来的研究应该在相同的实验设置中比较这两种断奶策略,同时也关注对犊牛的影响。