Shih Emily, Squiers John J, Brinkman William T, Harrington Katherine B, Schaffer Justin M, DiMaio J Michael, Ryan William H
Department of Cardiothoracic Surgery, The Heart Hospital Baylor Scott and White, Plano, Texas.
Baylor Scott and White Research Institute, Dallas, Texas.
Ann Thorac Surg Short Rep. 2022 Dec 26;1(2):307-310. doi: 10.1016/j.atssr.2022.12.009. eCollection 2023 Jun.
Recent reports that the Ross procedure restores normal life expectancy in young adults with aortic valve disease have renewed interest in this complex procedure. Because only a few centers perform a high volume of Ross procedures, there are limited data on the safety of learning and teaching the Ross procedure.
A total of 234 consecutive adult patients at a single center underwent the Ross procedure performed by an experienced surgeon acting as the primary operator (n = 186; 1994-2021) or mentoring surgeon (n = 48; 2001-2021). Cumulative sum analysis of cardiopulmonary bypass times was performed to evaluate learning curves as primary surgeon and mentored surgeon. Kaplan-Meier analysis was used to estimate long-term survival and freedom from Ross-related reintervention.
Patients' mean age was 42 ± 11 years; 169 (72%) were male. Baseline demographic characteristics were similar between cohorts. Operative death occurred in 5 (2%) patients: 3 (2%) as primary surgeon and 2 (4%) as mentor ( = .28). In-hospital reoperation was required in 8 (3%) patients: 6 (3%) as primary surgeon and 2 (4%) as mentor ( = .75). Up to 10 years, there was no difference in survival between primary operator cases and mentored cases (94.4% [91.2%-97.9%]) vs 95.8% [90.3%-100%]; log-rank, = .85).
Although the Ross procedure is technically complex, it can be taught to experienced aortic root surgeons without compromising short- or long-term outcomes.
最近有报道称,罗斯手术可恢复患有主动脉瓣疾病的年轻成年人的正常预期寿命,这重新引发了人们对这一复杂手术的兴趣。由于只有少数几个中心进行大量的罗斯手术,关于学习和教授罗斯手术安全性的数据有限。
在一个中心,共有234例连续的成年患者接受了罗斯手术,手术由一位经验丰富的外科医生作为主刀医生(n = 186;1994 - 2021年)或指导医生(n = 48;2001 - 2021年)进行。对体外循环时间进行累积和分析,以评估作为主刀医生和指导医生的学习曲线。采用Kaplan-Meier分析来估计长期生存率和免于与罗斯手术相关的再次干预的概率。
患者的平均年龄为42±11岁;169例(72%)为男性。两组患者的基线人口统计学特征相似。5例(2%)患者发生手术死亡:主刀医生组3例(2%),指导医生组2例(4%)(P = 0.28)。8例(3%)患者需要进行院内再次手术:主刀医生组6例(3%),指导医生组2例(4%)(P = 0.75)。长达10年,主刀医生组病例和指导医生组病例的生存率无差异(94.4%[91.2% - 97.9%]对95.8%[90.3% - 100%];对数秩检验,P = 0.85)。
尽管罗斯手术技术复杂,但可以教授给有经验的主动脉根部外科医生,而不会影响短期或长期疗效。