Farooq Faiq, Hassan Shabee U, Farooq Fahad, Farooq Faizan, Tareen Muhammad Samee Khan
Internal Medicine, Portsmouth Hospitals University NHS Trust, Portsmouth, GBR.
Cardiology, Portsmouth Hospitals University NHS Trust, Portsmouth, GBR.
Cureus. 2024 Dec 10;16(12):e75460. doi: 10.7759/cureus.75460. eCollection 2024 Dec.
Cardiology, a high-acuity medical specialty, has traditionally emphasised technical expertise, often overshadowing the critical role of non-technical skills (NTS). This imbalance stems from the historical focus on procedural competence and clinical knowledge in cardiology training and practice, leaving a significant gap in the development of crucial interpersonal and cognitive abilities. However, emerging evidence highlights the significant impact of NTS on patient outcomes, team dynamics, and overall healthcare efficiency. This review explores the importance of NTS in cardiology whilst drawing parallels with other high-stakes fields, such as aviation, surgery, and emergency medicine, which have successfully integrated NTS frameworks. These fields are particularly relevant due to their similar requirements for rapid decision-making under pressure, team-based approaches, and the potential for severe consequences in case of errors. Key NTS domains relevant to cardiology include leadership, such as in guiding cardiac teams effectively during procedures and emergencies; cooperation and resource management, such as focusing on optimising team performance and resource allocation in cardiac care units; communication and interaction, such as clear and concise information exchange during complex cardiac interventions; assessment and decision-making such as making critical choices in time-sensitive situations; situational awareness (SA) that maintains a comprehensive understanding of the patient's condition and surrounding environment; and coping with stress, which involves managing personal and team stress during and after high-pressure situations. The integration of NTS into cardiology practice is essential for improving patient care, reducing healthcare costs, and preventing clinician burnout. Despite the recognition of NTS' importance, there is a notable lack of structured training and validated assessment tools in cardiology. This absence poses a significant challenge to the implementation of NTS, as it hinders the systematic development and evaluation of these crucial skills amongst cardiologists. For instance, whilst technical skills in procedures like angiography are rigorously assessed, there is limited formal evaluation of NTS, for instance, a cardiologist's ability to lead a team effectively during a cardiac emergency. This review advocates for the development and implementation of NTS training and evaluation methods suitable for cardiology, emphasising the need for a balanced skill set that complements technical proficiency with social and cognitive abilities. Future research should focus on adapting existing tools or developing new ones to address the unique challenges of cardiology teams and foster safer, more effective patient care. Specific areas for investigation include developing cardiology-specific NTS assessment tools, creating structured NTS training programmes for cardiology fellows, evaluating the impact of NTS training on patient outcomes in cardiac care, and exploring the relationship between NTS proficiency and technical skill performance in cardiology procedures. By addressing these research gaps and developing targeted NTS interventions, cardiology can foster a more comprehensive approach to professional development, ultimately leading to improved patient care and healthcare efficiency in this critical field.
心脏病学是一门高敏锐度的医学专业,传统上一直强调技术专长,常常使非技术技能(NTS)的关键作用黯然失色。这种失衡源于心脏病学培训和实践中历来对程序能力和临床知识的关注,在关键的人际和认知能力发展方面留下了巨大差距。然而,新出现的证据凸显了非技术技能对患者治疗结果、团队动态以及整体医疗效率的重大影响。本综述探讨了非技术技能在心脏病学中的重要性,同时将其与其他高风险领域进行类比,如航空、外科手术和急诊医学,这些领域已成功整合了非技术技能框架。由于这些领域在压力下快速决策、基于团队的方法以及错误可能导致严重后果等方面有相似要求,所以它们具有特别的相关性。与心脏病学相关的关键非技术技能领域包括领导力,例如在手术和紧急情况期间有效指导心脏团队;合作与资源管理,例如在心脏护理单元注重优化团队绩效和资源分配;沟通与互动,例如在复杂的心脏干预过程中进行清晰简洁的信息交流;评估与决策,例如在时间敏感的情况下做出关键选择;态势感知(SA),即对患者病情和周围环境保持全面了解;以及应对压力,这涉及在高压情况期间及之后管理个人和团队的压力。将非技术技能整合到心脏病学实践中对于改善患者护理、降低医疗成本以及预防临床医生倦怠至关重要。尽管认识到非技术技能的重要性,但心脏病学领域明显缺乏结构化培训和经过验证的评估工具。这种缺失对非技术技能的实施构成了重大挑战,因为它阻碍了心脏病专家系统地发展和评估这些关键技能。例如,虽然血管造影等手术中的技术技能会得到严格评估,但非技术技能的正式评估却很有限,比如心脏病专家在心脏紧急情况期间有效领导团队的能力。本综述主张开发和实施适合心脏病学领域的非技术技能培训和评估方法,强调需要一套平衡的技能组合,将技术熟练程度与社交和认知能力相结合。未来的研究应专注于改编现有工具或开发新工具,以应对心脏病学团队面临的独特挑战,并促进更安全、更有效的患者护理。具体的研究领域包括开发针对心脏病学的非技术技能评估工具、为心脏病学实习生创建结构化的非技术技能培训项目、评估非技术技能培训对心脏护理中患者治疗结果的影响,以及探索心脏病学手术中非技术技能熟练程度与技术技能表现之间的关系。通过填补这些研究空白并开展有针对性的非技术技能干预措施,心脏病学可以培养一种更全面的专业发展方法,最终在这个关键领域改善患者护理和医疗效率。