Kylyshbayeva Gulnar, Bishimbayeva Nazira, Jatayev Sativaldy, Eliby Serik, Shavrukov Yuri
Faculty of Natural Sciences, Central Asian Innovation University, Shymkent 160000, Kazakhstan.
Research Institute for Biology and Biotechnology Problems, Al-Farabi Kazakh National University, Almaty 050040, Kazakhstan.
Plants (Basel). 2024 Dec 31;14(1):92. doi: 10.3390/plants14010092.
Polyethylene glycol (PEG), especially at high molecular weights, is highly soluble in water, and these solutions have reduced water potential. It is convenient to use PEG in hydroponics (liquid nutrient solution) for experiments with plants. However, some authors have been found to describe the application of PEG to plants incorrectly, such as drought, dehydration, osmotic, or water stresses, which can mislead readers. The presented opinion paper shows our arguments for a terminology in such experiments that is strictly limited to 'PEG-induced' or 'simulated' or 'mimicked' dehydration, and osmotic or water stresses, with the best option being 'PEG-induced dehydration'. The most popular term, 'drought', is inappropriate to be used for hydroponics at all, with or without PEG. Traditionally, drought stress study was related to only plants in soil or other substrates mixed with soil. Based on 139 published papers, the examples presented in our opinion paper can demonstrate differences in gene expression between plants grown in containers with soil and under PEG-induced stress in hydroponics. Researchers can carry out any type of experiments suitable for the purposes of their study. However, clear and correct description of experiments and careful interpretation of the results are strongly required, especially with PEG, to avoid incorrect information. In all cases, at the final stage, results of experiments in controlled conditions have to be verified in field trials with naturally occurring drought.
聚乙二醇(PEG),尤其是高分子量的聚乙二醇,在水中具有高度溶解性,并且这些溶液的水势会降低。在水培(液体营养液)中使用PEG对植物进行实验很方便。然而,一些作者在描述PEG对植物的应用时存在错误,如干旱、脱水、渗透或水分胁迫等,这可能会误导读者。本文献展示了我们对于此类实验术语的观点,即严格限定为“PEG诱导的”或“模拟的”或“模仿的”脱水、渗透或水分胁迫,最佳选择是“PEG诱导的脱水”。最常用的术语“干旱”根本不适用于水培,无论是否添加PEG。传统上,干旱胁迫研究仅涉及种植在土壤或与土壤混合的其他基质中的植物。基于139篇已发表的论文,我们在本文献中给出的例子可以证明种植在装有土壤的容器中的植物与水培中PEG诱导胁迫下的植物之间基因表达的差异。研究人员可以进行适合其研究目的的任何类型的实验。然而,强烈需要对实验进行清晰正确的描述并仔细解释结果,特别是对于PEG实验,以避免错误信息。在所有情况下,在最后阶段,必须在自然发生干旱的田间试验中验证在受控条件下的实验结果。