Fallah Daryavarsari Sobhan, Nascimbene Roberto
Department DICAr, University of Pavia, 27100 Pavia, Italy.
Istituto Universitario di Studi Superiori IUSS-Department STS, Scuola Universitaria Superiore Pavia, 27100 Pavia, Italy.
Materials (Basel). 2024 Dec 27;18(1):66. doi: 10.3390/ma18010066.
This study evaluates the API 650 design procedure for steel storage tanks, incorporating nonlinear dynamic analysis with large deformation effects. Focusing on seismic vulnerability, the case study examines storage tanks proposed for construction in Naples, Italy, assessing their performance under site-specific seismic conditions. A target spectrum and 20 earthquake records were selected to reflect regional seismic characteristics. Initial tank thicknesses were calculated using API 650 guidelines and subsequently analyzed through nonlinear time-history simulations in SAP2000. Results reveal that thicknesses derived from API 650s linear average spectrum equations are insufficient for real seismic demands. Through a trial-and-error methodology, optimal thicknesses were determined to ensure satisfactory performance across all seismic records. Key findings highlight significant variations in mode participation, the frequent occurrence of elephant-foot buckling in tanks with lower H/R ratios, and the limitations of linear spectral analysis for realistic earthquake scenarios. Given the vital role of storage tanks in the oil and gas industry, this study emphasizes the need to integrate nonlinear time history analysis into design processes to enhance seismic resilience, particularly in high-risk regions.
本研究评估了钢质储罐的API 650设计程序,该程序纳入了考虑大变形效应的非线性动力分析。以地震易损性为重点,该案例研究考察了拟建于意大利那不勒斯的储罐,评估了它们在特定场地地震条件下的性能。选择了一个目标谱和20条地震记录以反映区域地震特征。储罐的初始厚度按照API 650指南进行计算,随后通过SAP2000中的非线性时程模拟进行分析。结果表明,根据API 650线性平均谱方程得出的厚度不足以满足实际地震要求。通过反复试验方法,确定了最佳厚度,以确保在所有地震记录下都有令人满意的性能。主要研究结果突出了模态参与的显著差异、较低高径比储罐中频繁出现的象足屈曲,以及线性谱分析在实际地震场景中的局限性。鉴于储罐在石油和天然气行业中的重要作用,本研究强调有必要将非线性时程分析纳入设计过程,以提高抗震能力,特别是在高风险地区。