Parmigiani Giovanna, Benevento Marcello, Solarino Biagio, Margari Anna, Ferorelli Davide, Buongiorno Luigi, Catanesi Roberto, Carabellese Felice, Del Casale Antonio, Ferracuti Stefano, Mandarelli Gabriele
Department of Law, University of Modena and Reggio Emilia, Modena, Italy.
Interdisciplinary Department of Medicine, University of Bari "Aldo Moro", Bari, Italy.
Psychiatry Res. 2025 Feb;344:116343. doi: 10.1016/j.psychres.2024.116343. Epub 2024 Dec 25.
Obtaining informed consent in vulnerable populations like children and adolescents, is a relevant issue and raises ethical concerns. Minors are considered unable to consent to treatment, and permission from guardians is required for them. Nevertheless, several studies have been carried out on the competence of pediatric patients, with mixed results. Following PRISMA guidelines, a systematic review was performed to assess children and adolescents' decisional capacity to consent to treatment. The search strategy identified 2,790 studies, including 10 that survived full-text screening and evaluation. Studies included in the analysis evaluated the decision-making capacity of minors using the MacArthur Competency Assessment Tool - Treatment (MacCAT-T), the Adolescent Psychiatric Patient Competency Questionnaire (CQ-ChP); the Measure of Competency (MOC), the Measure of Competency- Hypothetical (MOCHyp). Overall, minors over the age of 13 showed an acceptable decisional capacity. However, further research, preferably on larger groups, is needed to shed more light on this topic.
在儿童和青少年等弱势群体中获得知情同意是一个相关问题,并引发了伦理关注。未成年人被认为无能力同意接受治疗,他们需要监护人的许可。然而,已经针对儿科患者的能力开展了多项研究,结果不一。遵循PRISMA指南,进行了一项系统评价,以评估儿童和青少年同意接受治疗的决策能力。检索策略识别出2790项研究,其中10项通过了全文筛选和评估。纳入分析的研究使用麦克阿瑟治疗能力评估工具(MacCAT-T)、青少年精神病患者能力问卷(CQ-ChP)、能力测评(MOC)、假设能力测评(MOCHyp)来评估未成年人的决策能力。总体而言,13岁以上的未成年人表现出可接受的决策能力。然而,需要进一步开展研究,最好是针对更大规模的群体,以更清楚地了解这一主题。