Carter Emma
Assessment and Evaluation Research Centre, Faculty of Education, University of Melbourne, Melbourne, Vic., Australia.
Child Adolesc Ment Health. 2025 Feb;30(1):96-98. doi: 10.1111/camh.12750. Epub 2025 Jan 13.
Universal school-based mental health interventions present a promising approach to addressing youth mental health challenges; however, evidence suggests their effectiveness is often limited and unsustained. One contributing factor to this issue is the frequent superficial involvement of students in the design, implementation and evaluation of initiatives. In response, this paper advocates for the urgent prioritisation of student voice within these programmes, using in-depth and purposive qualitative approaches that empower youth to actively co-create and shape interventions. Research highlights that incorporating student voice can yield vital insights into what is effective and ineffective in programmes, particularly for marginalised groups. Moreover, engaging students in co-designing methodologies that help amplify their voices ensures research processes are better aligned with their needs and preferences, fostering greater ownership and improved outcomes. This shift, which repositions students as active collaborators rather than passive recipients, has the potential to enhance both the effectiveness and equity of initiatives.
基于学校的普遍心理健康干预措施为应对青少年心理健康挑战提供了一种很有前景的方法;然而,有证据表明,这些措施的效果往往有限且难以持续。造成这一问题的一个因素是,学生在项目的设计、实施和评估中常常只是表面参与。作为回应,本文主张在这些项目中迫切优先考虑学生的声音,采用深入且有针对性的定性方法,使青少年有能力积极共同创造并塑造干预措施。研究强调,纳入学生的声音可以对项目中哪些有效、哪些无效产生至关重要的见解,特别是对于边缘化群体而言。此外,让学生参与共同设计有助于放大他们声音的方法,可确保研究过程更好地符合他们的需求和偏好,增强他们的主人翁意识并改善成果。这种转变将学生重新定位为积极的合作者而非被动的接受者,有可能提高项目的有效性和公平性。