Bryant D D
J Natl Med Assoc. 1985 Feb;77(2):113-7.
It has been written, "Material problems are easy to solve. It is the moral and ethical implications that reveal the defects in human nature."(1) Organ transplantation allows physicians to manipulate the course of, or to even surmount, the inevitable deterioration of human organ systems. To date, necessary reexaminations of ethical and moral beliefs have not kept pace with the tremendous surge in surgical prowess. Opposing viewpoints on the ethics of transplantation have been so emotive that the differing protagonists have been unable to reach a consensus for a national donor policy. This multifaceted dispute involves questions about costs and priorities, the problem of choice, the quality of life, the definition of death, and the welfare of the individual and society.
“物质问题容易解决。而道德和伦理层面的问题才揭示了人性的缺陷。”(1)器官移植使医生能够控制人体器官系统不可避免的衰退过程,甚至超越这一过程。迄今为止,对伦理道德观念的必要重新审视未能跟上外科技术的巨大飞跃。关于移植伦理的对立观点如此情绪化,以至于不同的支持者无法就国家捐赠政策达成共识。这场多方面的争论涉及成本和优先事项、选择问题、生活质量、死亡的定义以及个人和社会的福利等问题。