Colombari Michela, Troakes Claire, Verzeletti Andrea, Al-Sarraj Safa
Institute of Legal Medicine of Brescia, University of Brescia, Piazzale Spedali Civili, 1, Brescia, 25123, Italy.
London Neurodegenerative Diseases Brain Bank, Institute of Psychiatry, Psychology & Neuroscience, King's College London, London, UK.
Int J Legal Med. 2025 May;139(3):1287-1299. doi: 10.1007/s00414-025-03418-0. Epub 2025 Jan 20.
The diagnosis of abusive head trauma (AbHT) in children is a challenging one that needs to be differentiated from natural disease and accidental head injury (AcHT). There is increasing evidence from the Neuroradiology field showing spinal cord injury in children subject to AbHT, which has, so far, been poorly investigated pathologically. In this study we retrospectively reviewed the forensic records of 110 paediatric head injury cases over an eight-year-period. The records included detailed circumstances of death and clinical history alongside neuropathology, ophthalmic pathology and osteo-articular pathology. Based on the final multidisciplinary agreement, the 110 case were grouped into AbHT (n = 40), AcHT (n = 9), not clearly accidental or abusive ("undetermined" (UHT) n = 8) and non-traumatic brain injury (NTBI, n = 53). The spinal cord pathology present within each group was compared. Spinal subdural haematoma (SDH) was present in 71% of AbHT and 50% of AcHT cases and were located predominantly at the thoracolumbar level. In AbHT cases without spinal SDH, the suspected mechanism of injury was that of head impact rather than shaking, whilst cases of AcHT with spinal SDH were associated with direct trauma to the spinal cord. Injury of spinal nerve roots in AbHT was almost three times that seen in the accidental head injury group (58% vs. 17%). The study shows that pathological examination of the spinal cord and spinal nerve roots is of high value in investigating AHT and may help in differentiating AbHT from AcHT.
儿童虐待性头部创伤(AbHT)的诊断颇具挑战性,需要与自然疾病和意外头部损伤(AcHT)相区分。神经放射学领域越来越多的证据表明,遭受AbHT的儿童存在脊髓损伤,而迄今为止,这方面的病理研究还很匮乏。在本研究中,我们回顾性分析了8年间110例儿科头部损伤病例的法医记录。这些记录包括详细的死亡情况、临床病史以及神经病理学、眼科病理学和骨关节病理学资料。根据最终的多学科共识,将110例病例分为AbHT组(n = 40)、AcHT组(n = 9)、不明确为意外或虐待的“未确定”(UHT)组(n = 8)和非创伤性脑损伤(NTBI,n = 53)组。比较了每组中的脊髓病理学情况。脊髓硬膜下血肿(SDH)在71%的AbHT病例和50%的AcHT病例中出现,主要位于胸腰段水平。在没有脊髓SDH的AbHT病例中,疑似损伤机制为头部撞击而非摇晃,而伴有脊髓SDH的AcHT病例与脊髓直接创伤有关。AbHT病例中脊髓神经根损伤几乎是意外头部损伤组的三倍(58%对17%)。该研究表明,脊髓和脊髓神经根的病理检查在调查AHT中具有很高价值,可能有助于区分AbHT和AcHT。