Vanka Anita, Johnston Katherine T, Delbanco Tom, DesRoches Catherine M, Garcia Annalays, Salmi Liz, Blease Charlotte
Division of General Medicine, Department of Medicine, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center, Boston, MA, United States.
Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA, United States.
JMIR Med Educ. 2025 Jan 20;11:e59301. doi: 10.2196/59301.
Patients in the United States have recently gained federally mandated, free, and ready electronic access to clinicians' computerized notes in their medical records ("open notes"). This change from longstanding practice can benefit patients in clinically important ways, but studies show some patients feel judged or stigmatized by words or phrases embedded in their records. Therefore, it is imperative that clinicians adopt documentation techniques that help both to empower patients and minimize potential harms.
At a time when open and transparent communication among patients, families, and clinicians can spread more easily throughout medical practice, this inquiry aims to develop informed guidelines for documentation in medical records.
Through a series of focus groups, preliminary guidelines for documentation language in medical records were developed by health professionals and patients. Using a structured focus group decision guide, we conducted 4 group meetings with different sets of 27 participants: physicians experienced with writing open notes (n=5), patients accustomed to reviewing their notes (n=8), medical student educators (n=7), and resident physicians (n=7). To generate themes, we used an iterative coding process. First-order codes were grouped into second-order themes based on the commonality of meanings.
The participants identified 10 important guidelines as a preliminary framework for developing notes sensitive to patients' needs.
The process identified 10 discrete themes that can help clinicians use and spread patient-centered documentation.
美国患者最近获得了联邦政府强制规定的、免费且便捷的电子途径,可查阅其病历中临床医生的电子化记录(“开放病历”)。这一与长期以来的做法不同的改变,在临床上对患者有益,但研究表明,一些患者会因病历中嵌入的文字或短语而感到被评判或受辱。因此,临床医生必须采用有助于增强患者权能并尽量减少潜在危害的记录技巧。
在患者、家属和临床医生之间开放透明的沟通能够更轻松地在医疗实践中传播之际,本研究旨在制定关于病历记录的明智指南。
通过一系列焦点小组,由卫生专业人员和患者制定了病历记录语言的初步指南。我们使用结构化的焦点小组决策指南,与不同组别的27名参与者进行了4次小组会议:有书写开放病历经验的医生(n = 5)、习惯查看自己病历的患者(n = 8)、医学生教育工作者(n = 7)和住院医师(n = 7)。为了生成主题,我们采用了迭代编码过程。基于意义的共性,将一阶编码分组为二阶主题。
参与者确定了10条重要指南,作为制定满足患者需求的病历的初步框架。
该过程确定了10个不同的主题,可帮助临床医生使用并推广以患者为中心的记录方式。