Wolfe Kelly R, Broach Reagan, Clark Caelah, Gerk Andrea, Kelly Sarah L, Maloney Emily H, Neutts Ariann, Patteson Hilary, Payan Marisa, Riessen Sarah, Watson Sarah, Caprarola Sherrill D, Davidson Jesse A
Department of Pediatrics, University of Colorado Anschutz Medical Campus, Aurora.
Children's Hospital Colorado, Aurora.
JAMA Netw Open. 2025 Jan 2;8(1):e2456324. doi: 10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2024.56324.
A recent advisory from the American Heart Association delineated the potential benefits of developmental care for hospitalized children with congenital heart disease (CHD) and a critical gap in research evaluating the association of such inpatient programs with neurodevelopmental outcomes.
To investigate associations between the Cardiac Inpatient Neurodevelopmental Care Optimization (CINCO) program interventions, delirium, and neurodevelopment in young children (newborn through age 2 years) hospitalized with CHD.
DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: This cohort study used quality improvement data from inpatient cardiac units at a tertiary care children's hospital in the US. Participants were children aged 0 to 2 years who were admitted for at least 7 days from September 1, 2018, to September 1, 2023. The CINCO program was implemented on September 1, 2020, in 6-month plan-do-study-act phases.
The 5 CINCO interventions were medical and/or nursing order panels, developmental kits, bedside developmental plans, caregiver mental health support handouts, and developmental care rounds.
Number of days with delirium per patient, which was measured using the Cornell Assessment of Pediatric Delirium (a score higher than 9 indicated delirium). Neurodevelopment was measured using the Bayley Scales of Infant and Toddler Development, Fourth Edition (BSID-4).
The full sample included 1331 qualifying admissions for 1019 unique pediatric patients (median [range] age at admission, 3.65 [0-34.62] months; 771 males [57.9%]), with a subcohort of 121 unique patients (median [range] age at admission, 0.00 [0-9.85] months; 77 males [63.6%]) whose initial hospitalization occurred before age 10 months and who underwent BSID-4 evaluation at age 12 months or older. The mean (SD) number of days with delirium per patient was stable for 2 years prior to CINCO implementation, decreased by 54.0% between phases 1 and 2 of the CINCO program (from 3.05 [0.60] to 1.38 [0.21]), and then remained stable over time. Each of the 5 CINCO interventions was associated with lower delirium after false discovery rate (FDR) correction (eg, medical and/or nursing order panel: B = -1.376 [95% CI, -1.767 to -0.986]; F2,1273 = 47.767; partial η2 = 0.036; P < .001). Mean (SD) BSID-4 cognitive index scores were stable for 2 years prior to implementation, higher between phases 1 and 2 of the program (from 81.67 [14.14] to 93.92 [19.43]), and then remained stable over time. Four of the 5 interventions were associated with higher BSID-4 cognitive scores after FDR correction (eg, bedside developmental plans: B = 8.585 [95% CI, 2.247-14.923]; F5, 101 = 7.221; partial η2 = 0.067; P = .008). Delirium was associated with lower BSID-4 cognitive scores. There were no associations between delirium and BSID-4 language or motor scores.
This cohort study found that among hospitalized children with CHD, the implementation of an inpatient developmental care program was associated with reduced incidence of delirium and higher cognitive scores. Pediatric cardiac centers may consider adopting these low-cost, low-risk, generalizable program interventions.
美国心脏协会最近的一份咨询报告阐述了发育照护对患有先天性心脏病(CHD)的住院儿童的潜在益处,以及在评估此类住院项目与神经发育结局之间关联的研究中存在的重大差距。
调查心脏住院神经发育照护优化(CINCO)项目干预措施、谵妄与患有CHD的住院幼儿(新生儿至2岁)神经发育之间的关联。
设计、地点和参与者:这项队列研究使用了美国一家三级护理儿童医院住院心脏科的质量改进数据。参与者为2018年9月1日至2023年9月1日期间入院至少7天的0至2岁儿童。CINCO项目于2020年9月1日分6个月的计划-执行-研究-行动阶段实施。
CINCO的5项干预措施为医疗和/或护理医嘱面板、发育套件、床边发育计划、照顾者心理健康支持手册以及发育照护查房。
每位患者的谵妄天数,使用康奈尔儿科谵妄评估量表进行测量(得分高于9表明存在谵妄)。神经发育使用贝利婴幼儿发展量表第四版(BSID-4)进行测量。
完整样本包括1019名独特儿科患者的1331次符合条件的入院(入院时的中位年龄[范围]为3.65[0 - 34.62]个月;771名男性[57.9%]),其中一个亚组为121名独特患者(入院时的中位年龄[范围]为0.00[0 - 9.85]个月;77名男性[63.6%]),他们在10个月龄之前首次住院,并在12个月龄及以上接受了BSID-4评估。在CINCO实施前的2年里,每位患者谵妄的平均(标准差)天数保持稳定,在CINCO项目的第1阶段和第2阶段之间减少了54.0%(从3.05[0.60]降至1.38[0.21]),然后随时间保持稳定。在错误发现率(FDR)校正后,CINCO的5项干预措施中的每一项都与较低的谵妄发生率相关(例如,医疗和/或护理医嘱面板:B = -1.376[95%CI,-1.767至-0.986];F2,1273 = 47.767;偏η2 = 0.036;P <.001)。在实施前的2年里,BSID-4认知指数得分的平均(标准差)保持稳定,在项目的第1阶段和第2阶段之间得分更高(从81.67[14.14]升至93.92[19.43]),然后随时间保持稳定。在FDR校正后,5项干预措施中的4项与较高的BSID-4认知得分相关(例如,床边发育计划:B = 8.585[95%CI,2.247 - 14.923];F5, 101 = 7.221;偏η2 = 0.067;P = 0.008)。谵妄与较低的BSID-4认知得分相关。谵妄与BSID-4语言或运动得分之间无关联。
这项队列研究发现,在患有CHD的住院儿童中,实施住院发育照护项目与谵妄发生率降低和认知得分提高相关。儿科心脏中心可考虑采用这些低成本、低风险、可推广的项目干预措施。