Sacco Matteo Antonio, Aquila Valerio Riccardo, Gualtieri Saverio, Raffaele Roberto, Verrina Maria Cristina, Tarda Lucia, Gratteri Santo, Aquila Isabella
Institute of Legal Medicine, Department of Medical and Surgical Sciences, "Magna Graecia" University, 88100 Catanzaro, Italy.
Department of Medical and Surgical Sciences, "Magna Graecia" University, 88100 Catanzaro, Italy.
Biomedicines. 2025 Jan 14;13(1):193. doi: 10.3390/biomedicines13010193.
BACKGROUND/OBJECTIVES: Differential diagnosis of sudden cardiac death (SCD) remains challenging, particularly in cases lacking evident structural abnormalities. Cardiac markers have been proposed as useful tools for this differentiation in forensic contexts. However, key issues include the influence of postmortem interval (PMI) on marker stability and the limitations of traditional approaches that focus on pericardial fluid, which requires invasive sampling compared to peripheral blood. This study aimed to evaluate the potential of cardiac markers in peripheral blood for diagnosing SCD, addressing methodological concerns related to PMI, hemolysis, and sample handling.
This study analyzed 5 cardiac markers (creatine kinase-MB [CK-MB], myoglobin, troponin I [TnI], BNP, and D-dimer) in peripheral blood samples from 42 autopsied cadavers, divided into an SCD group and a control group. Marker levels were quantified using immunofluorescence, with cases meticulously selected to exclude confounding factors such as chronic diseases, pulmonary thromboembolism, and drowning. The study also accounted for potential degradation due to PMI, and evaluated the accuracy of point-of-care testing (POCT) in forensic samples.
The study identified statistically significant differences in myoglobin and TnI levels between the SCD group and the control group, though myoglobin's diagnostic reliability remains limited due to its lack of specificity for myocardial injury. TnI emerged as a more robust marker for SCD. Contrary to prior concerns, PMI showed no significant correlation with marker levels in samples handled without freeze-thaw cycles. Issues related to hemolysis were addressed, and no significant effects were observed from resuscitation maneuvers.
This study supports the potential use of cardiac markers, particularly TnI, in peripheral blood for postmortem SCD diagnosis, emphasizing the importance of rapid and systematic analysis to minimize hemolysis-related variability. While further validation is needed to confirm these findings, this approach offers a less invasive, economical, and practical method for forensic investigations.
背景/目的:心源性猝死(SCD)的鉴别诊断仍然具有挑战性,尤其是在缺乏明显结构异常的病例中。在法医背景下,心脏标志物已被提议作为这种鉴别的有用工具。然而,关键问题包括死后间隔时间(PMI)对标志物稳定性的影响以及传统方法的局限性,传统方法侧重于心包液,与外周血相比,这需要进行侵入性采样。本研究旨在评估外周血中心脏标志物对SCD的诊断潜力,解决与PMI、溶血和样本处理相关的方法学问题。
本研究分析了42例尸检尸体外周血样本中的5种心脏标志物(肌酸激酶同工酶MB[CK-MB]、肌红蛋白、肌钙蛋白I[TnI]、脑钠肽[BNP]和D-二聚体),分为SCD组和对照组。使用免疫荧光法定量标志物水平,精心挑选病例以排除慢性疾病、肺血栓栓塞和溺水等混杂因素。该研究还考虑了由于PMI导致的潜在降解,并评估了即时检验(POCT)在法医样本中的准确性。
该研究发现SCD组和对照组之间肌红蛋白和TnI水平存在统计学上的显著差异,尽管肌红蛋白由于对心肌损伤缺乏特异性,其诊断可靠性仍然有限。TnI成为SCD更可靠的标志物。与先前的担忧相反,在没有冻融循环处理的样本中,PMI与标志物水平没有显著相关性。解决了与溶血相关的问题,复苏操作未观察到显著影响。
本研究支持心脏标志物,特别是TnI,在外周血中用于死后SCD诊断的潜在用途,强调快速系统分析以最小化溶血相关变异性的重要性。虽然需要进一步验证以证实这些发现,但这种方法为法医调查提供了一种侵入性较小、经济且实用的方法。