Treiman R
J Exp Child Psychol. 1985 Feb;39(1):182-201. doi: 10.1016/0022-0965(85)90035-9.
The ability to make explicit judgments about speech sounds is important in learning to read and write an alphabetic system. However, even when children can make consistent judgments about sounds their judgments do not always agree with those of adults. In this study, some children from groups of kindergartners (mean age 5 years, 10 months) and first graders (mean age 6, 7) stated that /tr/ (as in "truck") did not begin with the sound /t/. This judgment was reflected in these children's spellings: They tended to spell /t/ before /r/ with CH, reflecting its affrication. Parallel results were found for /dr/. Further, some children judged that /c/ (as in "chill") and /j/ (as in "Jill") began with /t/ and /d/, respectively. They used the letters T and D to spell these sounds. Thus, children's attention to a phonetic level may result in judgments of speech sounds and spellings that are different from those of adults.
对语音做出明确判断的能力在学习读写字母系统中很重要。然而,即使孩子们能够对声音做出一致的判断,他们的判断也并非总是与成年人的判断一致。在这项研究中,一些来自幼儿园组(平均年龄5岁10个月)和一年级组(平均年龄6岁7个月)的孩子表示,/tr/(如在“truck”中)并非以/t/音开头。这种判断反映在这些孩子的拼写中:他们倾向于用CH在/r/之前拼写/t/,反映出它的塞擦音。对于/dr/也发现了类似的结果。此外,一些孩子判断/c/(如在“chill”中)和/j/(如在“Jill”中)分别以/t/和/d/开头。他们用字母T和D来拼写这些音。因此,孩子们对语音层面的关注可能会导致与成年人不同的语音和拼写判断。