McLain P L, Kirkwood C R
J Fam Pract. 1985 May;20(5):443-8.
Primary care physicians often make patient management decisions based in part on their own interpretations of radiographs. This important area of clinical decision making has not been previously analyzed in the literature. In this series of 294 consecutive radiographs from rural practice, interpretative disagreement between primary care providers and backup radiologists occurred 9.2 percent of the time, a discordance rate similar to that seen among radiologists in other studies. Although a majority of the films for which interpretative disagreement occurred had potential implications for influencing patient management, in only seven cases did actual case management vary from appropriate norms. Follow-up of cases where interpretative disagreement occurred revealed that in only two cases did unsatisfactory outcomes occur. Primary care physicians can provide high-quality radiographic interpretations that, when coupled with clinical information, yield extremely low rates of error or potential for poor patient outcomes.
基层医疗医生常常部分基于他们自己对X光片的解读来做出患者管理决策。这一临床决策的重要领域此前尚未在文献中得到分析。在这一系列来自农村医疗实践的连续294张X光片中,基层医疗提供者与后备放射科医生之间的解读分歧出现了9.2%的次数,这一不一致率与其他研究中放射科医生之间的情况相似。尽管出现解读分歧的大多数X光片对影响患者管理有潜在意义,但实际病例管理仅在7例中与适当规范有所不同。对出现解读分歧的病例进行随访发现,只有2例出现了不满意的结果。基层医疗医生能够提供高质量的X光片解读,当与临床信息相结合时,产生错误率极低或患者预后不佳可能性极低的结果。