Idsøe-Jakobsen Ingvild, Dombestein Heidi, Lawton Rebecca, Wiig Siri
SHARE-Centre for Resilience in Healthcare, Faculty of Health Sciences, University of Stavanger, Stavanger, Norway.
School of Psychology, University of Leeds, UK and Yorkshire Quality and Safety Research Group, Bradford Institute of Health Research, Bradford, UK.
J Patient Saf. 2025 Jun 1;21(4):246-255. doi: 10.1097/PTS.0000000000001323. Epub 2025 Feb 6.
Patients receiving homecare are living their everyday lives in their own homes. Adapting care to individual needs, preferences, risks, and family situations is seen as essential. The overall aim of this study was to develop empirical knowledge of risk perception in homecare services. The research question that guided the study was: How is a shared perception of risk between health care professionals and leaders a part of providing high-quality care within a homecare setting?
The research design was a multiple-embedded case study including 3 single cases. Participants were recruited from 3 Norwegian municipalities. Two focus group interviews were conducted in each municipality. In total, 19 informants participated, including 11 homecare department leaders and 8 health care professionals. The data were analyzed using thematic analysis according to Braun and Clarke's 6-phase thematic analysis.
Two higher-order themes were developed from the data: "Risk perception is a collective understanding" and "A flawed system requires adapting just to make it work." The study showed that, in the homecare departments, leaders' and health care professionals' opinion, flexibility and professional discussions are key to enhancing the system's adaptive capacity. High-quality care is always perceived as person-centered and adaptive. Overgeneralizations and the use of guidelines were perceived as demanding. The findings also showed that making sense of and managing risks within a homecare setting is complex.
Bridging the gaps by conceptualizing and acting upon risks in the homecare setting constitutes a fundamental part of adaptive capacity at a system level. However, better alignment of system demands to local risks is needed for sustainable and safe services.
接受居家护理的患者在自己家中度过日常生活。使护理适应个人需求、偏好、风险和家庭情况被视为至关重要。本研究的总体目标是积累关于居家护理服务中风险认知的实证知识。指导该研究的研究问题是:在居家护理环境中,医护人员和领导者之间对风险的共同认知如何成为提供高质量护理的一部分?
研究设计为包含3个单案例的多重嵌入式案例研究。参与者从挪威的3个自治市招募。在每个自治市进行了两次焦点小组访谈。共有19名受访者参与,包括11名居家护理部门领导和8名医护人员。根据布劳恩和克拉克的6阶段主题分析法,使用主题分析法对数据进行分析。
从数据中提炼出两个高阶主题:“风险认知是一种集体理解”和“有缺陷的系统需要调整才能运行”。研究表明,在居家护理部门,领导和医护人员的观点、灵活性和专业讨论是增强系统适应能力的关键。高质量护理始终被视为以患者为中心且具有适应性。过度概括和使用指南被认为要求过高。研究结果还表明,在居家护理环境中理解和管理风险很复杂。
通过在居家护理环境中对风险进行概念化并采取行动来弥合差距,是系统层面适应能力的基本组成部分。然而,为了实现可持续和安全的服务,需要使系统需求与当地风险更好地匹配。