Das Suparna, Kasher Paul, Waqar Mueez, Parry-Jones Adrian, Patel Hiren
The University of Manchester, Manchester, England, UK.
F1000Res. 2024 Nov 25;12:1252. doi: 10.12688/f1000research.139256.3. eCollection 2023.
A cerebral arteriovenous malformation (cAVM) is an abnormal tangle of cerebral blood vessels. The consensus document by the Joint Writing Group (JWG) highlighted which cAVM features should be recorded. Subsequent publications have reported cAVM angioarchitecture, but it is unknown if all followed the JWG recommendations. The aim of this systematic review was to describe use of the JWG guidelines. A database search, using the PRISMA checklist, was performed. We describe the proportion of publications that used JWG reporting standards, which standards were used, whether the definitions used differed from the JWG, or if any additional angiographic features were reported. Out of 4306 articles identified, 105 were selected, and a further 114 from other sources. Thirty-three studies (33/219; 15%) specifically referred to using JWG standards. Since the JWG publication, few studies have used their standards to report cAVMs. This implies that the angioarchitecture of cAVMs are not routinely fully described.
脑动静脉畸形（cAVM）是脑血管的异常缠结。联合写作组（JWG）的共识文件强调了应记录哪些cAVM特征。随后的出版物报道了cAVM的血管构筑，但尚不清楚是否所有研究都遵循了JWG的建议。本系统评价的目的是描述JWG指南的使用情况。使用PRISMA清单进行了数据库检索。我们描述了使用JWG报告标准的出版物比例、使用了哪些标准、所使用的定义是否与JWG不同，或者是否报告了任何额外的血管造影特征。在识别出的4306篇文章中，选择了105篇，另外从其他来源选取了114篇。33项研究（33/219；15%）特别提到使用JWG标准。自JWG发表以来，很少有研究使用其标准来报告cAVM。这意味着cAVM的血管构筑没有得到常规的全面描述。
