Mayer Romy M, Gubler Andrea, Attin Thomas, Zehnder Matthias
Clinic for Conservative and Preventive Dentistry, University of Zurich Center for Dental Medicine, Zurich, Switzerland.
Front Dent Med. 2024 Aug 29;5:1447459. doi: 10.3389/fdmed.2024.1447459. eCollection 2024.
Traditionally, internal tooth bleaching was performed using sodium perborate slurries. These are banned in some areas for potential carcinogenic effects. More recently, highly concentrated hydrogen peroxide gels have been used, which may cause dentin degradation. Consequently, the search for ideal internal tooth bleaching agents is still on. This study compared pure ROS-releasing granules regarding their liberation of oxidizing species, pH induction, bleaching of blood-stained dentin, and effects on mechanical dentin properties.
The ROS-releasing granules under investigation were sodium perborate, carbamide peroxide, and sodium percarbonate in aqueous suspension (4:3, wt/wt). The bleaching efficacy of these suspensions was compared in blood-stained human dentin ( = 6) . In addition, effects on mechanical dentin integrity were tested using bovine dentin beams ( = 9) exposed to a 3-point bending test (ISO 4049) after immersion in test suspensions or control solutions (35% HO and physiological saline) for 1 week.
Granules release between 21.5% and 35.2% (wt/wt) of HO equivalent. The sodium-containing granules (perborate and percarbonate) caused an alkaline pH of 10.3 and 10.6, respectively. The carbamide peroxide suspension was acidic (pH 3.9), as was the 35% HO solution used as a control (pH 2.2). All the suspensions bleached the blood-stained dentin, albeit with a lesser overall effect by sodium percarbonate (one-way ANOVA and Tukey's HSD, < 0.05). The acidic preparations caused a severe (over 50%) reduction in flexural strength of the dentin ( < 0.05 compared to physiological saline solution), while the alkaline counterparts did not.
Sodium perborate granules in aqueous suspension combined good de-staining properties with limited untoward effects on dentin integrity. Further studies are required to identify alternative compounds with a lesser general health concern.
传统上,内源性牙齿漂白使用过硼酸钠糊剂。由于其潜在的致癌作用,在一些地区已被禁止使用。最近,高浓度过氧化氢凝胶被用于牙齿漂白,但可能导致牙本质降解。因此,寻找理想的内源性牙齿漂白剂的工作仍在继续。本研究比较了纯活性氧释放颗粒在氧化物质释放、pH值诱导、对血渍牙本质的漂白作用以及对牙本质机械性能的影响。
所研究的活性氧释放颗粒为过硼酸钠、过氧化脲和过碳酸钠的水悬浮液(4:3,重量/重量)。比较这些悬浮液对血渍人牙本质(n = 6)的漂白效果。此外,使用牛牙本质梁(n = 9)测试对牙本质机械完整性的影响,将其在测试悬浮液或对照溶液(35%过氧化氢和生理盐水)中浸泡1周后进行三点弯曲试验(ISO 4049)。
颗粒释放相当于21.5%至35.2%(重量/重量)的过氧化氢。含钠颗粒(过硼酸盐和过碳酸盐)分别导致pH值为10.3和10.6的碱性环境。过氧化脲悬浮液呈酸性(pH 3.9),用作对照的35%过氧化氢溶液也是酸性(pH 2.2)。所有悬浮液均能漂白血渍牙本质,不过过碳酸钠的总体效果较小(单因素方差分析和Tukey's HSD检验,P < 0.05)。酸性制剂导致牙本质弯曲强度严重降低(超过50%)(与生理盐水溶液相比,P < 0.05),而碱性制剂则不会。
水悬浮液中的过硼酸钠颗粒具有良好的脱色性能,对牙本质完整性的不良影响有限。需要进一步研究以确定对总体健康影响较小的替代化合物。