Giangrasso J, Smith R K
Ann Emerg Med. 1985 Jun;14(6):573-9. doi: 10.1016/s0196-0644(85)80783-6.
We prospectively studied medical personnel compliance with antitetanus prophylaxis in 211 patients with wounds in three emergency departments. The guidelines were incorrectly followed in 13.4% of the patients, with 88.9% of the mistakes resulting from overimmunization. The most common mistake was the practice of giving tetanus and diphtheria toxoid (Td) to a patient with a clean wound who had complete primary immunization and a booster within ten years. This mistake accounted for 63% of the mistakes. The next most common, accounting for 18.5%, was the practice of giving Td and tetanus immune globulin to the never-immunized patient who had sustained a clean wound. Overimmunization increases the possibility of adverse reactions, and undertreatment places the patient at risk for tetanus.
我们前瞻性地研究了三个急诊科211例伤口患者的医疗人员破伤风预防措施的依从性。13.4%的患者未正确遵循指南,其中88.9%的错误是过度免疫所致。最常见的错误是,对伤口清洁、已完成基础免疫且在十年内接受过加强免疫的患者接种破伤风和白喉类毒素(Td)。该错误占所有错误的63%。第二常见的错误(占18.5%)是,对伤口清洁但从未免疫的患者接种Td和破伤风免疫球蛋白。过度免疫会增加不良反应的可能性,而治疗不足会使患者面临破伤风风险。