Whitworth James W, SantaBarbara Nicholas J, Nosrat Sanaz, Pebole Michelle M, Cripe Bradley G, McKeon Grace
National Center for PTSD, VA Boston Healthcare System, Boston, MA, USA.
Psychiatry Department, Boston University Chobanian & Avedisian School of Medicine, Boston, MA, USA.
Ment Health Phys Act. 2023 May 25;25. doi: 10.1016/j.mhpa.2023.100523.
There is a growing amount of experimental evidence demonstrating therapeutic chronic effects of exercise (e.g., resistance exercise, running, and walking) on PTSD symptoms. However, it is currently unclear how individuals with PTSD experience exercise within individual exercise sessions (e.g., pleasurable or distressing), and if these acute experiences influence PTSD symptoms over time.
The objective of this study was to examine the acute effects of high intensity resistance exercise on affect, perceived arousal, and distress among individuals who screened positive for PTSD, using a randomized controlled design. Additionally, this study sought to explore longitudinal relations among affect, arousal, distress, and PTSD symptom severity.
This study analyzed pooled data from two methodologically similar randomized controlled trials (i.e., a pilot and replication study). Participants (n = 52) were randomly assigned to exercise or non-exercise time-matched control. Data were analyzed with a series of longitudinal mixed-effects regression models.
The analyses suggest that positive affect increased, and distress decreased significantly during exercise sessions, relative to control. Independent of group, increases in positive affect and decreases in distress also significantly predicted decreases in PTSD symptom severity over the course of the study.
Taken together, these findings suggest that high intensity resistance exercise is safe for individuals who screen positive for PTSD, pleasurable, and may have a therapeutic impact on trauma survivors. No evidence for symptom exacerbation was found. Future experimental studies are needed to verify these findings and determine if the observed relationships are similar for other exercise modes, durations, and intensities.
越来越多的实验证据表明运动(如抗阻运动、跑步和步行)对创伤后应激障碍(PTSD)症状具有慢性治疗作用。然而,目前尚不清楚PTSD患者在单次运动过程中的体验(如愉悦或痛苦),以及这些即时体验是否会随着时间影响PTSD症状。
本研究的目的是采用随机对照设计,检验高强度抗阻运动对PTSD筛查呈阳性个体的情感、感知唤醒和痛苦的即时影响。此外,本研究还试图探究情感、唤醒、痛苦与PTSD症状严重程度之间的纵向关系。
本研究分析了两项方法学上相似的随机对照试验(即一项试点研究和一项重复研究)的汇总数据。参与者(n = 52)被随机分配到运动组或与运动时间匹配的非运动对照组。数据采用一系列纵向混合效应回归模型进行分析。
分析表明,与对照组相比,运动期间积极情感增加,痛苦显著降低。不考虑分组情况,在研究过程中,积极情感的增加和痛苦的降低也显著预测了PTSD症状严重程度的降低。
综上所述,这些发现表明高强度抗阻运动对PTSD筛查呈阳性的个体是安全的、令人愉悦的,并且可能对创伤幸存者具有治疗作用。未发现症状加重的证据。未来需要进行实验研究来验证这些发现,并确定对于其他运动方式、持续时间和强度,观察到的关系是否相似。