Liu Yingzhao, Chen Xiaoye, Shen Xingqian, Xia Kaijun, Liu Qin, Zhou Renhong, Leng Yangming, Xiao Hongjun, Liu Bo
Department of Otorhinolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery, Union Hospital, Tongji Medical College, Huazhong University of Science and Technology, Wuhan, China.
Institute of Otorhinolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery, Tongji Medical College, Huazhong University of Science and Technology, Wuhan, China.
J Vestib Res. 2025 May;35(3):121-131. doi: 10.1177/09574271251313801. Epub 2025 Jan 15.
BackgroundRamsay Hunt syndrome with dizziness (RHSD), vestibular neuritis (VN), and idiopathic sudden sensorineural hearing loss with vertigo (SHLV) all present with acute vestibular symptoms, and no study has compared the semicircular canal (SCC) deficits among them.ObjectiveThis study aimed to use video head impulse test (vHIT) to compare the SCC injury patterns in RHSD, VN, and SHLV.MethodsTwenty-three RHSD patients, 44 VN patients, and 70 SHLV patients were enrolled. The vestibulo-ocular reflex gain and incidence of corrective saccades of anterior, horizontal, and posterior SCC (ASCC, HSCC, and PSCC) were examined using vHIT. Pathological vHIT results referred to decreased VOR gain and presence of corrective saccades.Results(1) The pathological rate of each SCC in RHSD group was the highest. (2) Impairment pattern of SCCs can be divided into 7 types based on vHIT results. The pattern of ASCC + HSCC + PSCC disability was the most common in RHSD patients (12/23, 52.2%). In the VN group, the HSCC deficit alone was the most common (16/44, 36.4%), followed by HSCC + ASCC impairment (13/44, 29.5%). In SHLV patients, the most common type was the PSCC deficit alone (26/70, 37.1%). (3) The system cluster analysis revealed that the injury of all SCCs in RHSD patients, the deficit of HSCC alone in VN patients, and the impairment of PSCC alone in SHLV patients showed the farthest distance from other injury patterns.ConclusionSCCs deficit showed more severe and extensive vestibular impairment in RHSD compared with VN and SHLV, suggesting these three peripheral acute vestibular disorders may have different pathophysiologic mechanisms.
伴有头晕的拉姆齐·亨特综合征(RHSD)、前庭神经炎(VN)和特发性突聋伴眩晕(SHLV)均表现为急性前庭症状,尚无研究对它们之间的半规管(SCC)功能缺陷进行比较。
本研究旨在使用视频头脉冲试验(vHIT)比较RHSD、VN和SHLV患者的半规管损伤模式。
纳入23例RHSD患者、44例VN患者和70例SHLV患者。使用vHIT检查前庭眼反射增益以及前、水平和后半规管(ASCC、HSCC和PSCC)的矫正扫视发生率。病理性vHIT结果指前庭眼反射增益降低和存在矫正扫视。
(1)RHSD组中每个半规管的病理性发生率最高。(2)根据vHIT结果,半规管的损伤模式可分为7种类型。ASCC + HSCC + PSCC功能障碍模式在RHSD患者中最常见(12/23,52.2%)。在VN组中,单纯HSCC功能缺陷最常见(16/44,36.4%),其次是HSCC + ASCC损伤(13/44,29.5%)。在SHLV患者中,最常见的类型是单纯PSCC功能缺陷(26/70,37.1%)。(3)系统聚类分析显示,RHSD患者所有半规管的损伤、VN患者单纯HSCC功能缺陷以及SHLV患者单纯PSCC功能障碍与其他损伤模式的距离最远。
与VN和SHLV相比,RHSD患者的半规管功能缺陷表现出更严重和广泛的前庭功能障碍,提示这三种外周急性前庭疾病可能具有不同的病理生理机制。