Levack B, Flannagan J P, Hobbs S
J Bone Joint Surg Br. 1985 May;67(3):416-9. doi: 10.1302/0301-620X.67B3.3997951.
Sixty-four patellar fractures treated either by internal fixation or by patellectomy were reviewed retrospectively from 3.5 to 10.1 years (average 6.2 years) after operation. Results were assessed subjectively and objectively. Of the 64 patients, 45% had a good result, 27% fair and 28% poor. On the whole, patellectomy produced better results (60% good, 20% fair, 20% poor), than internal fixation (31% good, 33% fair, 36% poor). Nevertheless, the best results of all were achieved by precise anatomical reduction of the patellar fracture and fixation with K-wires and a tension band. Where this could not be achieved, however, patellectomy gave the best results.
对64例采用内固定或髌骨切除术治疗的髌骨骨折患者进行回顾性研究,时间跨度为术后3.5至10.1年(平均6.2年)。从主观和客观两方面对结果进行评估。64例患者中,45%效果良好,27%一般,28%较差。总体而言,髌骨切除术的效果(60%良好,20%一般,20%较差)优于内固定(31%良好,33%一般,36%较差)。然而,所有治疗方法中效果最佳的是对髌骨骨折进行精确的解剖复位并用克氏针和张力带固定。但如果无法做到这一点,髌骨切除术的效果最佳。