Gastmans Chris, Mertens Evelyne, Palese Alvisa, Keogh Brian, Apolloni Francesca, Wiisak Johanna, Cabe Catherine Mc, Dimitriadou Maria, Galazzi Alessandro, Igoumenidis Michael, Stefanopoulos Nikos, Charitou Paraskevi, Papastavrou Evridiki, Suhonen Riitta, Chiappinotto Stefania
Department of Public Health and Primary Care, Centre for Biomedical Ethics and Law, KU Leuven, Leuven, Belgium.
Department of Medicine, University of Udine, Udine, Italy.
Int J Nurs Stud Adv. 2025 Jan 21;8:100296. doi: 10.1016/j.ijnsa.2025.100296. eCollection 2025 Jun.
Across the world, healthcare systems have become increasingly complex, making it more difficult for nurses to act ethically when faced with moral dilemmas. The COVID-19 pandemic in particular revealed ethical challenges, highlighting the need for nurses to attain high levels of moral competence. Nurses who attain moral competency provide superior patient care because they have integrated clinical competence with sensitivity to moral values. Understanding what comprises moral competence in nursing is crucial to stimulate and support consistent ethical behaviour. However, most studies to date on moral competence in nursing have been conducted at a national level and only from a particular stakeholders' perspective, thereby limiting their utility.
To explore and document the characteristics of the morally competent nurse from the perspectives of nurses and patient representatives practicing in Europe.
A descriptive qualitative study was conducted.
Semi-structured focus group discussions were conducted to collect data. Data were analysed with a descriptive thematic method.
A purposive sample of 38 nurses and 35 patient representatives was recruited. They were geographically spread across six European countries.
The overarching characteristic of a morally competent nurse that emerged from our thematic analyses of group discussions is that they are person-centred. This person-centred quality is expressed on intrapersonal and interpersonal levels. The theme 'main components of moral competence in nurses' can be divided into three subthemes: knowledge, skills, and attitudes.
This study provided a deeper understanding of moral competency in nurses, from both the perspective of nurses and patient representatives in Europe. Morally competent nurses are person-centred and possess the requisite knowledge, skills, and attitudes that foster positive relationships with patients and their families, as well as with their nursing colleagues. Pedagogically, the results should be useful for teaching how moral competence can be supported in practice and how nurses can be better prepared to deal with ethically sensitive care practices in constantly evolving healthcare systems.
在全球范围内,医疗保健系统日益复杂,这使得护士在面对道德困境时更难做出符合道德的行为。尤其是新冠疫情暴露出了伦理挑战,凸显了护士具备高水平道德能力的必要性。具备道德能力的护士能提供更优质的患者护理,因为他们将临床能力与对道德价值观的敏感度结合在了一起。了解护理中的道德能力包含哪些要素对于促进和支持一致的道德行为至关重要。然而,迄今为止,大多数关于护理道德能力的研究都是在国家层面进行的,且仅从特定利益相关者的角度展开,因此其效用有限。
从欧洲的护士和患者代表的角度探索并记录具备道德能力的护士的特征。
开展了一项描述性定性研究。
通过半结构化焦点小组讨论收集数据。采用描述性主题分析法对数据进行分析。
招募了38名护士和35名患者代表作为目的抽样样本。他们分布在欧洲的六个国家。
我们对小组讨论进行主题分析后得出,具备道德能力的护士的首要特征是以患者为中心。这种以患者为中心的特质在个人层面和人际层面都有所体现。“护士道德能力的主要组成部分”这一主题可细分为三个子主题:知识、技能和态度。
本研究从欧洲护士和患者代表的角度,对护士的道德能力有了更深入的理解。具备道德能力的护士以患者为中心,拥有必要的知识、技能和态度,能够与患者及其家属以及护理同事建立积极的关系。从教学角度来看,这些结果对于教授如何在实践中支持道德能力以及如何让护士更好地准备应对不断发展的医疗保健系统中符合伦理的敏感护理实践应该是有用的。