Soil moisture and porosity regulate microbial metabolism by influencing factors, such as system chemistry, substrate availability, and soil connectivity. However, accurately representing the soil environment and establishing a tractable microbial community that limits confounding variables is difficult. Here, we use a reduced-complexity microbial consortium grown in a glass bead porous media amended with chitin to test the effects of moisture and a structural matrix on microbial phenotypes. Leveraging metagenomes, metatranscriptomes, metaproteomes, and metabolomes, we saw that our porous media system significantly altered microbial phenotypes compared with the liquid incubations, denoting the importance of incorporating pores and surfaces for understanding microbial phenotypes in soils. These phenotypic shifts were mainly driven by differences in expression of and , which included a significant decrease in overall chitin degradation between porous media and liquid. Our findings suggest that the success of in porous media is likely related to its ability to repurpose carbon via the glyoxylate shunt amidst a lack of chitin degradation byproducts while potentially using polyhydroxyalkanoate granules as a C source. We also identified traits expressed by and others, including motility, stress resistance, and carbon conservation, that likely influence the metabolic profiles observed across treatments. Together, these results demonstrate that porous media incubations promote structure-induced microbial phenotypes and are likely a better proxy for soil conditions than liquid culture systems. Furthermore, they emphasize that microbial phenotypes encompass not only the multi-enzyme pathways involved in metabolism but also include the complex interactions with the environment and other community members.IMPORTANCESoil moisture and porosity are critical in shaping microbial metabolism. However, accurately representing the soil environment in tractable laboratory experiments remains a challenging frontier. Through our reduced complexity microbial consortium experiment in porous media, we reveal that predicting microbial metabolism from gene-based pathways alone often falls short of capturing the intricate phenotypes driven by cellular interactions. Our findings highlight that porosity and moisture significantly affect chitin decomposition, with environmental matrix (i.e., glass beads) shifting community metabolism towards stress tolerance, reduced resource acquisition, and increased carbon conservation, ultimately invoking unique microbial strategies not evident in liquid cultures. Moreover, we find evidence that changes in moisture relate to community shifts regarding motility, transporters, and biofilm formation, which likely influence chitin degradation. Ultimately, our incubations showcase how reduced complexity communities can be informative of microbial metabolism and present a useful alternative to liquid cultures for studying soil microbial phenotypes.