Otaki Farah, Ho Samuel B, Nair Bhavana, AlGurg Reem, Stanley Adrian, Khamis Amar Hassan, Paulus Agnes, Alsuwaidi Laila
Strategy and Institutional Excellence, Mohammed Bin Rashid University of Medicine and Health Sciences, Dubai Health, Dubai, United Arab Emirates.
Department of Health Services Research, Faculty of Health, Medicine, and Life Sciences (FHML), Care and Public Health Research Institute (CAPHRI), Maastricht University, Maastricht, The Netherlands.
PLoS One. 2025 Feb 27;20(2):e0308774. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0308774. eCollection 2025.
Although curricula teaching skills related to resilience are widely adopted, little is known about needs and attitudes regarding resilience training of undergraduate-medical-trainees in Middle-East-and-North-Africa-region. The purpose of this study is to investigate the value of an innovative curriculum developed through design-based-research to build resilience-skills among undergraduate-medical-trainees in the United-Arab-Emirates.
Convergent-mixed-methods-study-design was utilized. Quantitative data collection was through controlled random group allocation conducted in one cohort of undergraduate medical students(n = 47). Students were randomly allocated into the respective resilience-skills-building-course(study-group) versus an unrelated curriculum(control-group). All students were tested at baseline(test-1), at end of 8-week course(test-2), and again 8 weeks after end of course(test-3). Then students crossed over to the opposite course and again tested at end of 8 weeks(test-4). Testing at four timepoints consisted of questionnaires related to burnout-Maslach-Burnout-Inventory; anxiety-General-Anxiety-Disorder-7; and resilience- Connor-Davidson-Resilience-Scale. Quantitative data were analysed descriptively and inferentially. Qualitative data, constituting of students' perception of their experience with the course, was captured using virtual-focus-group-sessions. Qualitative analysis was inductive. Generated primary inferences were merged using joint-display-analysis.
Significant proportion of the students, at baseline, seemed to be at risk for burnout and anxiety, and would benefit from developing their resilience. There appeared to be no statistical differences in measures of burnout, anxiety, and resilience related to course delivery. Overall risk for anxiety among students increased following the COVID-19 lockdown. Qualitative analysis generated the 'Resilience-Skills'-Building-around-Undergraduate-Medical-Education-Transitions' conceptual model of five themes: Transitions, Adaptation, Added Value of course, Sustainability of effects of course, and Opportunities for improving course. Merging of findings led to a thorough understanding of how the resilience-skills'-building-course affected students' adaptability.
This study indicates that a resilience-skills'-building-course may not instantly affect medical trainees' ratings of burnout, anxiety, and resilience. However, students likely engage with such an innovative course and its content to acquire and deploy skills to adapt to changes.
尽管教授与复原力相关技能的课程已被广泛采用,但对于中东和北非地区本科医学实习生的复原力培训需求和态度却知之甚少。本研究的目的是调查通过基于设计的研究开发的创新课程对于培养阿拉伯联合酋长国本科医学实习生复原力技能的价值。
采用了收敛性混合方法研究设计。定量数据收集通过在一组本科医学生(n = 47)中进行的对照随机分组进行。学生被随机分配到各自的复原力技能培养课程(研究组)和无关课程(对照组)。所有学生在基线(测试1)、8周课程结束时(测试2)以及课程结束8周后再次进行测试(测试3)。然后学生交叉到相反的课程,并在8周结束时再次进行测试(测试4)。在四个时间点的测试包括与倦怠(马氏倦怠量表)、焦虑(广泛性焦虑障碍7项量表)和复原力(康纳-戴维森复原力量表)相关的问卷。对定量数据进行描述性和推断性分析。定性数据由学生对课程体验的感知组成,通过虚拟焦点小组会议收集。定性分析采用归纳法。使用联合展示分析合并生成的主要推论。
在基线时,相当比例的学生似乎有倦怠和焦虑风险,培养复原力对他们有益。与课程交付相关的倦怠、焦虑和复原力测量似乎没有统计学差异。在COVID-19封锁后,学生的总体焦虑风险增加。定性分析产生了“围绕本科医学教育过渡构建复原力技能”的概念模型,包含五个主题:过渡、适应、课程的附加价值、课程效果的可持续性以及改进课程的机会。研究结果的合并使我们对复原力技能培养课程如何影响学生的适应性有了全面的了解。
本研究表明,复原力技能培养课程可能不会立即影响医学实习生的倦怠、焦虑和复原力评分。然而,学生可能会参与这样的创新课程及其内容,以获得和运用技能来适应变化。