Kristiansen Håkon Emil, Kvernmoen Håkon, Kvaal Simen, Pedersen Thomas Bondo
Hylleraas Centre for Quantum Molecular Sciences, Department of Chemistry, University of Oslo, P.O. Box 1033 Blindern, N-0315 Oslo, Norway.
Department of Physics, University of Oslo, P.O. Box 1033 Blindern, N-0315 Oslo, Norway.
J Phys Chem A. 2025 Mar 13;129(10):2638-2654. doi: 10.1021/acs.jpca.4c07443. Epub 2025 Mar 3.
We introduce a simple definition of the weight of any given Slater determinant in the coupled-cluster state, namely as the expectation value of the projection operator onto that determinant. The definition can be applied to any coupled-cluster formulation, including conventional coupled-cluster theory, perturbative coupled-cluster models, nonorthogonal orbital-optimized coupled-cluster theory, and extended coupled-cluster theory, allowing for wave function analyses on par with configuration-interaction-based wave functions. Numerical experiments show that for single-reference systems the coupled-cluster weights are in excellent agreement with those obtained from the full configuration-interaction wave function. Moreover, the well-known insensitivity of the total energy obtained from truncated coupled-cluster models to the choice of orbital basis is clearly exposed by weights computed in the -transformed determinant basis. We demonstrate that the inseparability of the conventional linear parametrization of the bra (left state) for systems composed of noninteracting subsystems may lead to ill-behaved (negative or greater than unity) weights, an issue that can only be fully remedied by switching to extended coupled-cluster theory. The latter is corroborated by results obtained with quadratic coupled-cluster theory, which is shown numerically to yield a significant improvement.
我们引入了耦合簇态中任意给定斯莱特行列式权重的一个简单定义,即该行列式上投影算符的期望值。该定义可应用于任何耦合簇公式,包括传统耦合簇理论、微扰耦合簇模型、非正交轨道优化耦合簇理论和扩展耦合簇理论,从而能够进行与基于组态相互作用的波函数相当的波函数分析。数值实验表明,对于单参考体系,耦合簇权重与从完全组态相互作用波函数得到的权重非常吻合。此外,在变换后的行列式基中计算的权重清楚地揭示了截断耦合簇模型得到的总能量对轨道基选择的众所周知的不敏感性。我们证明,对于由非相互作用子系统组成的体系,传统的左矢(左态)线性参数化的不可分离性可能导致行为不良(负或大于1)的权重,这个问题只有通过转向扩展耦合簇理论才能得到完全解决。二次耦合簇理论得到的结果证实了后者,数值结果表明其有显著改进。