Malta Ginevra, Puntarello Maria, Midiri Mauro, D'Anna Tommaso, Zerbo Stefania, Argo Antonina
Department of Health Promotion, Mother and Childcare, Internal Medicine and Medical Specialties (PROMISE), Italy.
Forensic Medicine Unit. "Paolo Giaccone" University Hospital of Palermo, Italy.
Forensic Sci Int Synerg. 2025 Feb 17;10:100577. doi: 10.1016/j.fsisyn.2025.100577. eCollection 2025 Jun.
This systematic review explores women's homicidal strangulation using PRISMA method. A total of 40 Google Scholar, 26 PubMed and 4 manual searching articles were analyzed, while other sources were excluded due to lack of full texts, irrelevance, or outdated content. Review highlights gender violence as an underestimated issue and provides a socio-demographic analysis. Diagnosing strangulation can be challenging, particularly in absence of visible asphyxial signs in the external examination. Judicial authorities' collaboration and reliance on circumstantial evidence are crucial in forensic investigations. Strangulation is statistically prevalent in sexually motivated crimes and employs various methods. We reported four different strangulation cases at the Institute of Forensic Medicine, University of Palermo, to emphasize findings, forensic characteristics, and interpretation difficulties. The primary goal of this review is to shed light on homicidal strangulation's specific characteristics, given its underreported nature, and to stress the importance of mechanical asphyxia in forensic differential diagnosis. Distinguishing strangulation from other asphyxial deaths is difficult, as is identifying potential third-party involvement. This review also aims to provide key indicators that assist forensic pathologists in differentiating strangulation from other asphyxial causes of death. Future perspectives highlight the use of specific protocols, using artificial intelligence (AI), and instrumental investigations to support forensic pathologists in performing differential diagnoses and providing compatibility assessments.
本系统评价采用PRISMA方法探讨女性杀人勒颈案件。共分析了40篇来自谷歌学术、26篇来自PubMed的文章以及4篇手动检索的文章,而其他来源因缺乏全文、不相关或内容过时被排除。评价强调性别暴力是一个被低估的问题,并提供了社会人口学分析。诊断勒颈可能具有挑战性,尤其是在外部检查中没有明显窒息迹象的情况下。司法当局的合作以及对间接证据的依赖在法医调查中至关重要。从统计学角度来看,勒颈在性动机犯罪中很普遍,且采用多种方式。我们报告了巴勒莫大学法医学研究所的四起不同的勒颈案件,以强调调查结果、法医特征及解读难点。鉴于杀人勒颈事件报告不足的情况,本评价的主要目的是阐明其具体特征,并强调机械性窒息在法医鉴别诊断中的重要性。区分勒颈与其他窒息死亡情况困难,识别潜在第三方参与情况也同样困难。本评价还旨在提供关键指标,以协助法医病理学家区分勒颈与其他窒息性死因。未来展望强调使用特定方案、人工智能(AI)以及仪器调查,以支持法医病理学家进行鉴别诊断并提供一致性评估。