Meltzer Gabriella Y, Anderson G Brooke, Xie Xicheng, Casey Joan A, Schwartz Joel, Bell Michelle L, Ornelas Van Horne Yoshira, Fox Jared, Kioumourtzoglou Marianthi-Anna, Parks Robbie M
Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Columbia University Irving Medical Center, New York, NY, United States of America.
Department of Environmental and Radiological Health Sciences, Colorado State University, Fort Collins, CO, United States of America.
Environ Res Health. 2025 Jun 1;3(2):025003. doi: 10.1088/2752-5309/adb32b. Epub 2025 Feb 14.
Quantifying how hurricanes disrupt educational attainment is essential to evaluating the burden of climate-related disasters. Here, we examine the association between hurricane-force tropical cyclones and educational attainment among elementary and middle school students in all affected areas in the United States during the 2008/2009-2017/2018 school years. Educational performance was based on county-level average standardized test scores in math and reading/language arts (RLAs). Hurricane-force tropical cyclone-exposed counties were those that experienced a sustained maximal wind speed ⩾64 knots. We estimated the association between hurricane-force tropical cyclone exposure and long-term test scores using a Bayesian hierarchical linear model, accounting for time-varying covariates at the county and grade cohort level. For hurricane-exposed counties, compared with the rest of the state, there were better test scores in Florida in math ( = 0.14; 95% CrI: 0.02, 0.26; PP[ > 0] = 99.0%) and RLA ( = 0.11; 95% CrI: 0.02, 0.22; PP[ > 0] = 99.2%), and worse math scores in North Carolina ( = -0.16; 95% CrI: -0.29, -0.03; PP[ < 0] = 99.4%). Grade cohorts with more racialized and minoritized (e.g. Black, Hispanic, Indigenous) and socioeconomically disadvantaged students tended to have lower test scores, while grade cohorts with greater shares of students racialized as Asian and counties with more college-educated adults tended to have higher scores regardless of hurricane exposure. Disaster preparedness must maximize resilience to climate-related stressors' impacts on academic achievement, especially for vulnerable populations.
量化飓风如何扰乱教育成就对于评估气候相关灾害的负担至关重要。在此,我们研究了2008/2009 - 2017/2018学年期间,美国所有受影响地区的飓风级热带气旋与中小学学生教育成就之间的关联。教育表现基于县级数学和阅读/语言艺术(RLA)的平均标准化考试成绩。遭受飓风级热带气旋影响的县是那些经历持续最大风速⩾64节的县。我们使用贝叶斯分层线性模型估计了飓风级热带气旋暴露与长期考试成绩之间的关联,同时考虑了县级和年级队列水平上随时间变化的协变量。对于受飓风影响的县,与该州其他地区相比,佛罗里达州在数学方面的考试成绩更好( = 0.14;95%可信区间:0.02,0.26;PP[ > 0] = 99.0%),在RLA方面也是如此( = 0.11;95%可信区间:0.02,0.22;PP[ > 0] = 99.2%),而北卡罗来纳州的数学成绩更差( = -0.16;95%可信区间:-0.29,-0.03;PP[ < 0] = 99.4%)。具有更多种族化和少数族裔(如黑人、西班牙裔、原住民)以及社会经济弱势学生的年级队列往往考试成绩较低,而具有较高比例被归类为亚裔学生的年级队列以及拥有更多受过大学教育成年人的县,无论是否受到飓风影响,往往成绩更高。灾害准备必须最大限度地提高对气候相关压力源对学业成绩影响的恢复力,特别是对于弱势群体。