Bennett M J, Hahn J F
Anesthesiology. 1985 Jun;62(6):759-64. doi: 10.1097/00000542-198506000-00010.
Dose-response relationships for a 1:4 weight ratio-mixture of pancuronium and metocurine were studied during inhalational anesthesia with halothane and isoflurane in patients with and without renal failure. The time for recovery from 10 to 20% of control thumb twitch tension also was determined. In subjects with normal renal function, relaxant doses required for 95% twitch height suppression (ED95) were 50% of those predicted by simple addition of effects when used with a balanced anesthetic technique, 37% of predicted when used with 1.3 MAC halothane, and 25% of predicted when used with 1.3 MAC isoflurane (P less than 0.05). In subjects with renal failure, ED95 values for the combination were 40% of predicted when used with 1.2 MAC halothane and 45% of predicted when used with 1.2 MAC isoflurane (NS). For relaxants used singly in renal failure, pancuronium alone was slightly enhanced by 1.2 MAC halothane (85% of predicted), while 1.1 MAC isoflurane reduced the ED95 to 57% of predicted (P less than 0.05). Similar results were obtained for metocurine alone when used in renal failure (77 and 58% of predicted when used with halothane and isoflurane, respectively) (NS). Predicted values are published results for balanced anesthesia in normals. Recovery times were prolonged twofold in renal failure (P less than 0.05). Thus, the combination of pancuronium and metocurine is synergistic to the same degree in normals and in renal failure patients, but the total blockade produced by the combination is enhanced by halothane and isoflurane only in normals.
在有和没有肾衰竭的患者中,研究了泮库溴铵和美托咪酯按1:4重量比混合时在氟烷和异氟烷吸入麻醉期间的剂量-反应关系。还测定了从对照拇指抽搐张力的10%恢复到20%所需的时间。在肾功能正常的受试者中,当与平衡麻醉技术联合使用时,抑制95%抽搐高度所需的松弛剂剂量(ED95)为简单相加效应预测值的50%;当与1.3MAC氟烷联合使用时,为预测值的37%;当与1.3MAC异氟烷联合使用时,为预测值的25%(P<0.05)。在肾衰竭患者中,当与1.2MAC氟烷联合使用时,该组合的ED95值为预测值的40%;当与1.2MAC异氟烷联合使用时,为预测值的45%(无显著性差异)。在肾衰竭患者中单独使用松弛剂时,1.2MAC氟烷使泮库溴铵单独使用时略有增强(为预测值的85%),而1.1MAC异氟烷将ED95降至预测值的57%(P<0.05)。肾衰竭患者单独使用美托咪酯时也得到了类似结果(与氟烷和异氟烷联合使用时分别为预测值的77%和58%)(无显著性差异)。预测值是正常情况下平衡麻醉的已发表结果。肾衰竭患者的恢复时间延长了两倍(P<0.05)。因此,泮库溴铵和美托咪酯的组合在正常人和肾衰竭患者中具有相同程度的协同作用,但该组合产生的总阻滞作用仅在正常人中被氟烷和异氟烷增强。