Suppr超能文献

交叉性如何为职业治疗实践、教育和研究提供信息:一项范围综述。

How Intersectionality Informs Occupational Therapy Practice, Education, and Research: A Scoping Review.

作者信息

Smith Diane L, Ford Alesia, Samson Helina

机构信息

Diane L. Smith, OT, PhD, OTR, FAOTA, is Professor and Doctoral Capstone Coordinator, Department of Occupational Therapy, MGH Institute of Health Professions, Boston, MA;

Alesia Ford, OTD, OTR/L, is Occupational Therapist, Children's Friend and Services, Central Falls, RI.

出版信息

Am J Occup Ther. 2025 Mar 1;79(2). doi: 10.5014/ajot.2025.050970.

Abstract

IMPORTANCE

Lack of consideration of intersectionality by occupational therapy practitioners, faculty, and researchers can result in inequities experienced by students and clients served.

OBJECTIVE

To determine how intersectionality is represented in the scholarly literature used to inform occupational therapy practice, research, and education.

DATA SOURCES

A comprehensive database that includes CINAHL, MEDLINE, and PsycINFO.

STUDY SELECTION AND DATA COLLECTION

Inclusion criteria were peer-reviewed articles published between 2013 and 2023, written in English, and pertinent to the research question. The review used Covidence database and Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic reviews and Meta-Analyses extension for Scoping Reviews (PRISMA-ScR) guidelines, resulting in 36 articles identified as meeting all criteria. Any discrepancies were resolved through discussion among the authors.

FINDINGS

A data abstraction chart was developed, and analysis resulted in themes of education, practice, and research with specific subthemes. Findings revealed that the lack of an intersectional approach in education is often viewed negatively by diverse students, who experience a lack of belonging. Suggested strategies focused on reducing isolation and revising curricula to reflect student diversity. Intersectional issues in practice showed access disparities and a lack of occupational participation for diverse clients. Suggested strategies included consideration of the multilayered identities of clients using cultural humility and consideration of context. Strategies for research focused on using a collaborative approach to represent the intersectional lived experience of diverse populations.

CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE

Despite limited studies, intersectionality was identified as a lens for occupational therapy educators, practitioners, and researchers and as an important strategy to address issues faced by diverse students, resulting in more effective client-centered care. Plain-Language Summary: This study reviewed literature from occupational therapy and other health professions to determine how the concept of intersectionality is used to inform practice, education, and research. The study is needed because common Western-based practice is based on an individual, White, upper-middle class, able-bodied, cisgender perspective, which does not match the demographics or needs of clients. Results show that the intersectional identities of students and clients are often not being considered. Literature is emerging to provide educational, practice, and research strategies to address the diverse needs of occupational therapy students and clients by identifying and considering multiple and intersectional identities and the effect of context. The results challenge occupational therapy educators, practitioners, and researchers to consider the use of intersectionality moving forward to provide holistic, client-centered care. Positionality Statement: Diane Smith is a cisgender, White, able-bodied occupational therapy professor with a graduate degree and numerous publications regarding disability rights and intersectionality. Alesia Ford is a cisgender, Black, neurodivergent occupational therapy practitioner with a graduate degree and publications focused on increased diversity within the profession. Helina Samson is a cisgender, Black, able-bodied occupational therapy practitioner with a graduate degree. These lenses influence and may potentially bias our interpretation regarding critique of current strategies in education, practice, and research. For the purposes of this review, please note that LGBTQIA+ is not a standardized term, and the term used by the original researchers will be used (e.g., LGBTQ, LGBT).

摘要

重要性

职业治疗从业者、教员和研究人员若不考虑交叉性,可能会导致所服务的学生和客户遭遇不公平现象。

目的

确定交叉性在用于指导职业治疗实践、研究和教育的学术文献中是如何体现的。

数据来源

一个综合数据库,包括护理学与健康领域数据库(CINAHL)、医学期刊数据库(MEDLINE)和心理学文摘数据库(PsycINFO)。

研究选择与数据收集

纳入标准为2013年至2023年期间发表的、英文撰写的、与研究问题相关的同行评审文章。该综述采用了循证数据库以及系统评价与Meta分析扩展版的范围综述首选报告项目(PRISMA-ScR)指南,最终确定36篇文章符合所有标准。任何差异均通过作者之间的讨论得以解决。

研究结果

制定了一份数据提取图表,分析得出了教育、实践和研究等主题以及具体子主题。研究结果显示,教育中缺乏交叉性方法往往受到不同学生的负面看待,他们感到缺乏归属感。建议的策略集中在减少孤立感以及修订课程以反映学生的多样性。实践中的交叉性问题表现为不同客户在获取服务方面存在差距以及缺乏职业参与。建议的策略包括运用文化谦逊来考虑客户的多重身份以及考虑具体情境。研究策略侧重于采用协作方法来呈现不同人群的交叉生活经历。

结论与意义

尽管研究有限,但交叉性被确定为职业治疗教育工作者、从业者和研究人员的一个视角,也是解决不同学生所面临问题的一项重要策略,从而带来更有效的以客户为中心的护理。

通俗易懂的总结

本研究回顾了职业治疗及其他健康专业领域的文献,以确定交叉性概念是如何用于指导实践、教育和研究的。之所以需要这项研究,是因为常见的西方实践模式基于个体、白人、中上层阶级健全身体的顺性别视角,这与客户的人口统计学特征或需求不匹配。结果表明,学生和客户的交叉身份常常未被考虑。目前正在出现一些文献,通过识别和考虑多重交叉身份以及情境的影响,提供教育、实践和研究策略,以满足职业治疗学生和客户的多样化需求。这些结果促使职业治疗教育工作者、从业者和研究人员考虑今后运用交叉性来提供全面的、以客户为中心的护理。

立场声明

黛安·史密斯是一位顺性别、白人、身体健全的职业治疗教授,拥有研究生学位,发表了许多关于残疾权利和交叉性的文章。阿莱西亚·福特是一位顺性别、黑人、神经发育异常的职业治疗从业者,拥有研究生学位,其发表的文章专注于提高该行业的多样性。赫利娜·萨姆森是一位顺性别、黑人、身体健全的职业治疗从业者,拥有研究生学位。这些视角会影响并可能使我们对当前教育、实践和研究策略的批评性解读产生偏差。出于本综述的目的,请注意 LGBTQIA+ 不是一个标准化术语,将使用原始研究人员使用的术语(例如,LGBTQ、LGBT)。

文献AI研究员

20分钟写一篇综述,助力文献阅读效率提升50倍。

立即体验

用中文搜PubMed

大模型驱动的PubMed中文搜索引擎

马上搜索

文档翻译

学术文献翻译模型,支持多种主流文档格式。

立即体验