Lane Aaron, Quach Huy Q, Ovsyannikova Inna G, Kennedy Richard B, Ross Ted M, Einav Tal
Center for Vaccine Innovation, La Jolla Institute for Immunology, La Jolla, CA 92037, USA.
Vaccine Research Group, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, MN 55905, USA.
medRxiv. 2025 Feb 27:2025.02.26.25322965. doi: 10.1101/2025.02.26.25322965.
Most influenza vaccine studies evaluate acute antibody responses 1 month post-vaccination, leaving long-term immunity poorly understood. Here, we performed a combined analysis of 14 large-scale vaccine studies and conducted two new studies mapping antibody responses in high resolution from their inception out to 1 year post-vaccination. Vaccine antibody responses were classified as (<4x fold-change at 1 month and 1 year), (≥4x at 1 month, <4x at 1 year), or (≥4x at 1 month and 1 year). Surprisingly, >50% of vaccine recipients were weak across seasons, age groups, sexes, pre-vaccination titers, and high or standard vaccine doses. Peak fold-change at 1 month post-vaccination was strongly associated with the long-term response, with most transient responders achieving a maximum fold-change of 4x, while most durable responders reached ≥16x, with both groups maintaining these titers for 2 months (10-75 days post-vaccination). Using the weak, transient, and durable trajectories, a single time point early in the response (days 7-8 or 21) predicted an individual's response out to 1 year post-vaccination. These results demonstrate that influenza vaccine responses range from little-to-no response to eliciting strong-and-durable immunity, highlighting the stark heterogeneity that is consistently seen across influenza seasons.
大多数流感疫苗研究评估接种疫苗后1个月的急性抗体反应,而对长期免疫的了解甚少。在此,我们对14项大规模疫苗研究进行了综合分析,并开展了两项新研究,以高分辨率绘制从接种疫苗开始到接种后1年的抗体反应图谱。疫苗抗体反应被分类为(1个月和1年时变化倍数<4倍)、(1个月时≥4倍,1年时<4倍)或(1个月和1年时≥4倍)。令人惊讶的是,超过50%的疫苗接种者在不同季节、年龄组、性别、接种前滴度以及高剂量或标准剂量疫苗情况下反应都较弱。接种疫苗后1个月时的峰值变化倍数与长期反应密切相关,大多数短暂反应者的最大变化倍数为4倍,而大多数持久反应者达到≥16倍,两组在2个月(接种后10 - 75天)内维持这些滴度。利用弱反应、短暂反应和持久反应轨迹,反应早期的单个时间点(第7 - 8天或第21天)可以预测个体接种疫苗后1年的反应。这些结果表明,流感疫苗反应范围从几乎无反应到引发强烈且持久的免疫,突出了在流感季节中始终存在的明显异质性。