Hassan Nisreen Nabiel, Mattoo Khurshid, Khawaji Atheer, Najmi Hanan, Sadeli Almaha, Alshahrani Ahid Amer, Qahtani Abeer Ali, Alshehri Abdullah Hasan, Almarzouki Mai, Sayed Mohammed E
Department of Restorative Dental Sciences, College of Dentistry, Taibah University, Madinah 41477, Saudi Arabia.
Department of Prosthetic Dental Sciences, College of Dentistry, Jazan University, Jazan 45142, Saudi Arabia.
Polymers (Basel). 2025 Mar 6;17(5):699. doi: 10.3390/polym17050699.
This study determined the influence of surface treatment and protracted ageing on the shear bond strength (SBS) of orthodontic brackets bonded to CADCAM (milled) and 3D-printed polymethylmethacrylate (PMMA) provisional crowns (PCs). Eighty disc-shaped specimens [forty milled (CopraTemp WhitePeaks) [group (Gp) M] and forty printed (Asiga DentaTooth) (Gp P)] were divided into eight subgroups (Gp) based on surface treatment [no treatment (control) (Gp MC and Gp PC), coarse diamond (Gp MCD and Gp PCD), fine diamond (Gp MFD, and GP PFD) and sandblast (Gp MSB and Gp PSB)]. Orthodontic brackets were bonded (Assure Plus, Transbond XT), thermocycled (2200 cycles), and tested for SBS and failure (Adhesive Remnant Index) (ARI). Statistical tests included analysis of variance (ANOVA); Kruskal-Wallis (ARI ranks); and post hoc (Tukey, Dunn, and Bonferroni) for determining group differences at predetermined probability -values less than 0.05. SBS was significantly increased in Gp MSB (15.51 Mpa) and Gp PSB (14.11 Mpa), while the coarse diamond subgroups yielded the lowest mean SBS values [Gp MCD (11.28 Mpa) and Gp PCD (11.62 Mpa)]. The SBS of subgroups MFD, MSB, PCD, and PSB showed significant differences from those of their respective controls (Gp MC and Gp PC). Low ARI scores were observed in Gp MC (0.40) and Gp MSB (0.80), while higher scores were observed in Gp PCD (2.10). Both milled and printed PCs fulfil the clinical criteria of the minimum SBS for orthodontic brackets for long-term use. However, milled PC has better SBS and low ARI scores, which make it more clinically feasible for orthodontic treatments.
本研究确定了表面处理和长期老化对粘结于计算机辅助设计与制造(CADCAM,铣削)及3D打印聚甲基丙烯酸甲酯(PMMA)临时冠(PC)上的正畸托槽剪切粘结强度(SBS)的影响。八十个圆盘形样本[四十个铣削样本(CopraTemp WhitePeaks)[组(Gp)M]和四十个打印样本(Asiga DentaTooth)(Gp P)]根据表面处理方式分为八个亚组(Gp)[未处理(对照)(Gp MC和Gp PC)、粗粒度金刚石处理(Gp MCD和Gp PCD)、细粒度金刚石处理(Gp MFD和GP PFD)以及喷砂处理(Gp MSB和Gp PSB)]。将正畸托槽粘结(使用Assure Plus、Transbond XT)、进行热循环(2200次循环),并测试其SBS及失败情况(粘结剂残留指数,ARI)。统计检验包括方差分析(ANOVA);Kruskal-Wallis检验(ARI等级);以及用于在预定概率值小于0.05时确定组间差异的事后检验(Tukey、Dunn和Bonferroni检验)。Gp MSB(15.51兆帕)和Gp PSB(14.11兆帕)的SBS显著增加,而粗粒度金刚石亚组的平均SBS值最低[Gp MCD(11.28兆帕)和Gp PCD(11.62兆帕)]。MFD、MSB、PCD和PSB亚组的SBS与其各自的对照组(Gp MC和Gp PC)存在显著差异。在Gp MC(0.40)和Gp MSB(0.80)中观察到较低的ARI分数,而在Gp PCD(2.10)中观察到较高的分数。铣削和打印的PC均满足正畸托槽长期使用的最低SBS临床标准。然而,铣削PC具有更好的SBS和较低的ARI分数,这使其在正畸治疗中在临床上更可行。