Di Bonaventura Rina, Aiudi Denis, Chiesa Silvia, Pellerino Alessia, Bruno Francesco, Internò Valeria, Mazzarella Ciro, Pronello Edoardo, Colasanti Roberto, Somma Teresa, Ius Tamara, Della Pepa Giuseppe Maria, Barresi Valeria, D'Alessandris Quintino Giorgio, Rudà Roberta, Silvani Antonio
Department of Neurosurgery, Fondazione Policlinico Universitario A. Gemelli IRCCS, Largo Agostino Gemelli 8, Rome, 00168, Italy.
Neurosurgical Department, Università Politecnica Delle Marche, Marche General University Hospital, Ancona, Italy.
J Neurooncol. 2025 Mar 18. doi: 10.1007/s11060-025-05003-2.
Neuro-oncology is a multidisciplinary subspecialty that has evolved and expanded tremendously over the last 20 years. In Europe, notwithstanding a number of commendable initiatives, neither a specific neuro-oncology training curriculum nor a consensus on the ideal training tools have been set. In this context, the Youngster Committee of the Italian Association for Neuro-Oncology (AINO) has run a nationwide survey to take a snapshot of the current situation of neuro-oncology education in Italy.
Between July and November 2023, we distributed through AINO a 34-question survey addressed to all Italian care providers dealing with neuro-oncology, irrespective of specialty and level of experience, as per AINO mission. The questionnaire was disseminated using an open link. We analyzed and stratified answers according to epidemiological characteristics of the respondents, i.e. age, gender, role, years of experience, type and case load of their work Institutions, geographical region.
We collected 254 valid questionnaires. The majority of respondents were under 40 years old (62.6%); neurosurgeons formed the largest specialty group (48%). Residency was a key step for neuro-oncology education according to 33% of participants; notably, younger respondents gave a significantly more positive assessment of residency programs compared to older ones (72% vs. 56%, p = 0.0193). PhD programs in Italy are focused only on research, according to 30% of respondents. Regarding the tools for continuing medical education in neuro-oncology, a striking contrast between the ideal ones, which should be the frequent participation in dedicated courses (59% responses), and the actual one, which is scientific literature (55%), was recorded. Mentorship programs are rare and inconsistent and should be strengthened. More than 90% of participants declared multidisciplinary collaboration as fundamental. Multispecialty societies like AINO have a key role in strengthening education in neuro-oncology through the organization of structured post-graduate programs.
The results of this survey, by describing the status of the neuro-oncology training paths in Italy, can lay the foundation for initiatives aimed at harmonizing neuro-oncology education in Italy and Europe. The creation of a shared neuro-oncology curriculum and of a network of mentors is suggested.
神经肿瘤学是一个多学科亚专业,在过去20年中得到了巨大的发展和扩展。在欧洲,尽管有一些值得称赞的举措,但尚未制定具体的神经肿瘤学培训课程,也未就理想的培训工具达成共识。在此背景下,意大利神经肿瘤学协会(AINO)青年委员会开展了一项全国性调查,以了解意大利神经肿瘤学教育的现状。
2023年7月至11月期间,我们通过AINO向所有从事神经肿瘤学工作的意大利医疗服务提供者发放了一份包含34个问题的调查问卷,这些提供者不论专业和经验水平,均符合AINO的使命。问卷通过开放链接进行分发。我们根据受访者的流行病学特征,即年龄、性别、角色、工作经验年限、工作机构的类型和病例量、地理区域,对答案进行了分析和分层。
我们收集了254份有效问卷。大多数受访者年龄在40岁以下(62.6%);神经外科医生构成了最大的专业群体(48%)。33%的参与者认为住院医师培训是神经肿瘤学教育的关键步骤;值得注意的是,与年长受访者相比,年轻受访者对住院医师培训项目的评价明显更为积极(72%对56%,p = 0.0193)。30%的受访者表示,意大利的博士项目仅专注于研究。关于神经肿瘤学继续医学教育的工具,记录到理想的工具(应是频繁参加专门课程,59%的回复)与实际的工具(科学文献,55%)之间存在显著差异。导师计划很少且不一致,应予以加强。超过90%的参与者宣称多学科合作至关重要。像AINO这样的多专业协会通过组织结构化的研究生项目,在加强神经肿瘤学教育方面发挥着关键作用。
本次调查的结果通过描述意大利神经肿瘤学培训路径的现状,可为旨在协调意大利和欧洲神经肿瘤学教育的举措奠定基础。建议创建一个共享的神经肿瘤学课程和一个导师网络。