Lopez Piggott Maisy, Zaizay Zeela, Dean Laura, Zawolo Georgina, Parker Coleen, McCollum Rosalind
Department for International Public Health, Liverpool School of Tropical Medicine, Liverpool, L3 5QA, UK.
Actions Transforming Lives, Congo Town Backroad, Monrovia 1000, Liberia.
Res Involv Engagem. 2025 Mar 24;11(1):27. doi: 10.1186/s40900-025-00695-2.
Skin Neglected Tropical Diseases (NTD) can impact physical and mental well-being for persons affected due to discrimination and stigmatisation, often leading to feelings of disempowerment. Community engagement is important for NTD work to foster advocacy and empowerment; however, there is limited literature surrounding best practices for community engagement within research focused on skin NTDs. REDRESS is a participatory action research study, aimed at reducing the burden of skin NTDs through a person-centred approach that emphasises community engagement. This study explores the value of community engagement within REDRESS for individuals and the impact on the health system's ability to care for person's affected by skin NTDs.
Through a naturalistic paradigm, eleven purposively selected in-depth interviews and 21 in-depth interviews with reflective diary participants were conducted in Liberia. Participants included peer-researchers, co-researchers, and dual role participants (Ministry of Health implementers and REDRESS researchers). Taking an inductive epistemological position, data was thematically analysed around a value creation framework that considers different cycles of value creation for communities such as potential, immediate and transformative value.
This study revealed that REDRESS community engagement aligned with core UNICEF community engagement standards and identified seven themes relating to value creation cycles, participant position and enabling environments. Community engagement led to capacity building and collaboration, provided communities tools to make changes and share knowledge, and had transformative effects in trust and health seeking behaviours. The primary research revealed community engagement activities not seen elsewhere such as the involvement of persons affected as peer-researchers and communities taking part in project monitoring through keeping reflective diaries. Researchers' local involvement facilitated processes that would not otherwise occur, such as speaking local dialects and policy discussions. Importantly, power dynamics are carefully considered in the process. Few challenges have been discussed directly related to REDRESS, but individual challenges related to dual role time management, external factors, and differences in agendas.
Community engagement activities led to meaningful empowerment, ownership, sustainability, and partnership formation leading to broader health outcomes. Five areas of opportunity were identified, and recommendations to strengthen community engagement include capacity building, clearer communication and addressing power imbalances.
皮肤被忽视热带病(NTD)会因歧视和污名化影响患者的身心健康,常导致他们产生无力感。社区参与对于皮肤NTD防治工作以促进宣传和赋权很重要;然而,围绕以皮肤NTD为重点的研究中社区参与的最佳实践的文献有限。“补救”(REDRESS)是一项参与式行动研究,旨在通过以个人为中心的方法减轻皮肤NTD的负担,该方法强调社区参与。本研究探讨了“补救”项目中社区参与对个人的价值以及对卫生系统照顾皮肤NTD患者能力的影响。
采用自然主义范式,在利比里亚进行了11次有目的选择的深度访谈以及对21名反思日记参与者的深度访谈。参与者包括同伴研究人员、合作研究人员以及双重角色参与者(卫生部实施人员和“补救”项目研究人员)。从归纳认识论的角度出发,围绕一个价值创造框架对数据进行了主题分析,该框架考虑了社区价值创造的不同周期,如潜在价值、即时价值和变革性价值。
本研究表明,“补救”项目的社区参与符合联合国儿童基金会的核心社区参与标准,并确定了与价值创造周期、参与者角色和有利环境相关的七个主题。社区参与带来了能力建设与合作,为社区提供了做出改变和分享知识的工具,并对信任和就医行为产生了变革性影响。初步研究揭示了其他地方未见的社区参与活动,例如受影响者作为同伴研究人员的参与以及社区通过撰写反思日记参与项目监测。研究人员在当地的参与促进了一些原本不会发生 的过程,比如使用当地方言和进行政策讨论。重要的是,在这个过程中仔细考虑了权力动态。与“补救”项目直接相关的挑战很少被讨论,但存在与双重角色时间管理、外部因素和议程差异相关的个人挑战。
社区参与活动带来了有意义的赋权、自主、可持续性以及伙伴关系的形成,从而产生更广泛的健康成果。确定了五个机会领域,加强社区参与的建议包括能力建设、更清晰的沟通以及解决权力不平衡问题。