Kim S G, Seiden S W, Matos J A, Waspe L E, Fisher J D
Am J Cardiol. 1985 Jul 1;56(1):84-8. doi: 10.1016/0002-9149(85)90571-5.
The efficacy and tolerance of quinidine and procainamide used individually and in combination were studied in 19 patients with frequent ventricular premature complexes (VPCs). During single-drug treatment, the maximum tolerated dose of quinidine without extracardiac dose-related side effects was 1.6 +/- 0.21 g/day and that of procainamide was 4.1 +/- 1.05 g/day. During combination therapy with smaller doses (p less than 0.05) of quinidine (1.16 +/- 0.26 g/day) and procainamide (2.80 +/- 0.98 g/day), no patient had side effects. Before treatment, all patients had frequent (more than 60 per hour) VPCs and 17 had ventricular tachycardia on Holter monitoring. The frequency of VPCs was reduced to 22 +/- 19% with quinidine, 47 +/- 40% with procainamide and 9 +/- 11% with combination therapy (p less than 0.05, combination vs procainamide or quinidine alone). Individually, an effective regimen (more than 83% reduction of VPCs and abolition of ventricular tachycardia) was found in 5 patients (26%) receiving quinidine alone at maximal tolerated dose, in 4 (21%) receiving procainamide alone at maximal tolerated dose, and in 14 (74%) receiving combination therapy (p less than 0.01 vs quinidine or procainamide). Thus, the antiarrhythmic effects of quinidine and procainamide are additive. When quinidine or procainamide are additive. When quinidine or procainamide is ineffective because dose-related extracardiac side effects limit the maximal tolerated dose, combination therapy in smaller and tolerable doses avoids side effects and is more effective than either drug alone at the maximal tolerated dose.
对19例频发室性早搏(VPC)患者研究了奎尼丁和普鲁卡因胺单独及联合应用的疗效和耐受性。在单药治疗期间,无心脏外剂量相关副作用的奎尼丁最大耐受剂量为1.6±0.21g/天,普鲁卡因胺为4.1±1.05g/天。在联合使用较小剂量(p<0.05)的奎尼丁(1.16±0.26g/天)和普鲁卡因胺(2.80±0.98g/天)治疗期间,无患者出现副作用。治疗前,所有患者VPC频发(每小时超过60次),17例患者动态心电图监测有室性心动过速。VPC频率用奎尼丁降低至22±19%,用普鲁卡因胺降低至47±40%,联合治疗降低至9±11%(联合治疗与单独使用普鲁卡因胺或奎尼丁相比,p<0.05)。单独使用时,5例(26%)接受最大耐受剂量奎尼丁单药治疗、4例(21%)接受最大耐受剂量普鲁卡因胺单药治疗、14例(74%)接受联合治疗的患者中发现有效方案(VPC减少超过83%且室性心动过速消失)(与奎尼丁或普鲁卡因胺相比,p<0.01)。因此,奎尼丁和普鲁卡因胺的抗心律失常作用是相加的。当奎尼丁或普鲁卡因胺相加时。当奎尼丁或普鲁卡因胺因剂量相关的心脏外副作用限制最大耐受剂量而无效时,较小且可耐受剂量的联合治疗可避免副作用,且比最大耐受剂量的任一药物单独使用更有效。