Romeikat Nimue Lilith, Sullivan Frank, Daly Fergus, Kong Wenyan
Division of Population & Behavioural Science, Medicine School, University of St. Andrews, St. Andrews KY16 9TF, Scotland, UK.
J Clin Med. 2025 Mar 20;14(6):2116. doi: 10.3390/jcm14062116.
: Despite recent lung cancer screening (LCS) studies proving significant mortality reduction, comorbidities are a prominent issue affecting cost effectiveness, which is holding back national implementation. Incidental findings (IFs) of comorbidities make a significant contribution to delayed diagnoses and raise discussions about optimal management plans. This is particularly relevant to national lung cancer screening (NLCS), as the high-risk population qualifying for the screening often have increased likelihood for comorbidities due to their smoking history. : The Early Detection of Cancer of the Lung Scotland (ECLS) (ClinicalTrials.gov identifier NCT01925625) study showcases a targeted approach to NLCS by implementing the blood-based biomarker EarlyCDT-Lung test. Firstly, this paper explored the ECLS dataset for comorbidities present within the screening population at baseline A chi-square analysis was then undertaken to investigate the relationship of cohort allocation and incidence of new comorbidities over the five-year follow-up period. : High prevalence conditions were cardiovascular (38.5%), neurological/psychiatric (33.9%), gastrointestinal (29.8%), and respiratory (19.2%). While 20.3% of the total patient cohort showed a newly discovered comorbidity, there was no significant variation in new incidences between the intervention and control cohort. : When considering these results alongside the all-cause mortality reduction shown in previous analyses, they indicate that this targeted approach to LCS might help improve the benefit-harm ratio through the introduction of biomarkers. Further refining selection criteria for low-dose CT screening might contribute to minimising the risk of overdiagnosis and overtreatment.
尽管近期的肺癌筛查(LCS)研究证明可显著降低死亡率,但合并症是影响成本效益的一个突出问题,这阻碍了其在全国范围内的实施。合并症的偶然发现对延迟诊断有重大影响,并引发了关于最佳管理方案的讨论。这与国家肺癌筛查(NLCS)尤为相关,因为符合筛查条件的高危人群由于吸烟史,合并症的可能性通常更高。
苏格兰肺癌早期检测(ECLS)(ClinicalTrials.gov标识符NCT01925625)研究通过实施基于血液的生物标志物EarlyCDT-Lung检测,展示了一种针对NLCS的靶向方法。首先,本文探索了ECLS数据集中基线时筛查人群中存在的合并症。然后进行了卡方分析,以研究队列分配与五年随访期内新合并症发病率之间的关系。
高患病率的疾病包括心血管疾病(38.5%)、神经/精神疾病(33.9%)、胃肠道疾病(29.8%)和呼吸系统疾病(19.2%)。虽然总患者队列中有20.3%显示有新发现的合并症,但干预组和对照组之间新发病率没有显著差异。
将这些结果与之前分析中显示的全因死亡率降低情况相结合,表明这种针对LCS的靶向方法可能有助于通过引入生物标志物来提高利弊比。进一步完善低剂量CT筛查的选择标准可能有助于将过度诊断和过度治疗的风险降至最低。