Penel Nicolas, Cren Pierre-Yves, Ducroq Christophe, Laurent Estelle M N, Choukroun Gabriel, Hazzan Marc, Crie Dominique
Centre Oscar Lambret, Department of Medical Oncology, Lille University, 3 rue Combemale, Lille, 59020, France.
Department of Medical Oncology, Centre Oscar-Lambret, ULR-2694 - Metrics : évaluation des technologies de santé et des pratiques médicales, CHU de Lille, University of Lille, Lille, France.
BMC Med Educ. 2025 Mar 27;25(1):447. doi: 10.1186/s12909-025-06811-w.
There is limited data regarding what motivations are behind the choice of oncology (both medical oncology and radiation oncology) as a specialty among medical students. Therefore, the aim of this study is to identify the factors that motivate medical students to choose oncology as a specialty.
Medical students of classes 2022 and 2023 in the Universities of Lille and Amiens (North of France) were enrolled in a quantitative online survey. Chi-square automatic interaction detection (CHAID) and binary and multiple linear regressions were performed to identify the factors that determine the choice of specialty among the students.
Among 563 respondents (response rate: 45%) who participated in the survey, 14, 13, and 14 were considering oncology as their first (2.5%), second (2.3%), and third (2.5%) specialty choices, respectively. The CHAID analysis retained two factors: "rotation in the medical oncology unit" (p < .0001) and "identification with a physician practicing the desired specialty" (p = 0.049). The factors identified in the multivariate regression analysis (weighted according to first, second, or third choices) differed according to sex. In men, rotation in a radiation oncology unit (β = 0.190; p < 0.001) or a medical oncology unit (β = 0.227; p = 0.010) and interest in fundamental research (β = 0.063; p < 0.001) were positively associated with choosing oncology as a specialty, whereas working in rural areas (β=-0.094; p = 0.014) was negatively associated with choosing oncology as a specialty. In women, rotation in a medical oncology unit (β = 0.289; p < 0.001), interest in cultivating a long-term relationship with patients (β = 0.129; p < 0.001), and interest in a hospital-based career (β = 0.214;p < 0.001) were positively associated with choosing oncology as a specialty; whereas desire to see the results of treatments quickly (β=-0.143; p = 0.018) and working in rural areas (β=-0.153; p = 0.006) were negatively associated with choosing oncology as a specialty.
Experience during hospital rotations plays a crucial role in the specialty choices made by medical students. The motivations behind choosing oncology as a specialty differ according to gender. Intrinsic motivations (interests in fundamental research or in cultivating a long-term relationship with patients) and contextual factors (rural life or interest in a hospital-based career) influence the specialty choices of medical students.
关于医学生选择肿瘤学(包括医学肿瘤学和放射肿瘤学)作为专业背后的动机,相关数据有限。因此,本研究的目的是确定促使医学生选择肿瘤学作为专业的因素。
法国北部里尔大学和亚眠大学2022级和2023级的医学生参与了一项定量在线调查。采用卡方自动交互检测(CHAID)以及二元和多元线性回归来确定决定学生专业选择的因素。
在参与调查的563名受访者中(回复率:45%),分别有14人、13人和14人将肿瘤学视为他们的第一(2.5%)、第二(2.3%)和第三(2.5%)专业选择。CHAID分析确定了两个因素:“在医学肿瘤学科室轮转”(p < 0.0001)和“认同从事理想专业的医生”(p = 0.049)。多变量回归分析中确定的因素(根据第一、第二或第三选择加权)因性别而异。在男性中,在放射肿瘤学科室(β = 0.190;p < 0.001)或医学肿瘤学科室轮转(β = 0.227;p = 0.010)以及对基础研究的兴趣(β = 0.063;p < 0.001)与选择肿瘤学作为专业呈正相关,而在农村地区工作(β = -0.094;p = 0.014)与选择肿瘤学作为专业呈负相关。在女性中,在医学肿瘤学科室轮转(β = 0.289;p < 0.001)、对与患者建立长期关系的兴趣(β = 0.129;p < 0.001)以及对医院职业的兴趣(β = 0.214;p < 0.001)与选择肿瘤学作为专业呈正相关;而希望快速看到治疗结果的愿望(β = -0.143;p = 0.018)和在农村地区工作(β = -0.153;p = 0.006)与选择肿瘤学作为专业呈负相关。
医院轮转期间的经历在医学生的专业选择中起着关键作用。选择肿瘤学作为专业背后的动机因性别而异。内在动机(对基础研究的兴趣或对与患者建立长期关系的兴趣)和背景因素(农村生活或对医院职业的兴趣)会影响医学生的专业选择。