Franco-Rowe Carol Y, Lee-Winn Angela E, Williams Venice Ng, Lopez Connie, Tung Gregory J, Allison Mandy A
Prevention Research Center for Family and Child Health, Department of Pediatrics, University of Colorado Anschutz Medical Campus, 1890 North Revere Court Mailstop F443 Aurora, Aurora, CO, 80045, USA.
Department of Epidemiology, Colorado School of Public Health, University of Colorado Anschutz Medical Campus, 13001 E. 17th Place, MS B119, Aurora, CO, 80045, USA.
BMC Pregnancy Childbirth. 2025 Mar 28;25(1):369. doi: 10.1186/s12884-025-07473-8.
Clinical guidelines in the United States (U.S.) recommend a patient-centered approach to healthcare for pregnant people with substance use disorders (SUD); however, pregnant people with SUD often describe experiencing stigmatization and shame when seeking prenatal care. We explored the perspectives of pregnant and parenting people engaged with SUD treatment regarding their experiences with healthcare providers during the perinatal period to improve guidance for patient-centered care.
Using an adapted phenomenological approach, we conducted in-depth interviews with 22 pregnant and parenting people recruited from inpatient or outpatient substance use treatment centers in the U.S. state of Colorado. We developed an interview guide to explore participants' experiences during pregnancy, childbirth, and postpartum. We audio recorded, transcribed, and validated interviews for analyses. A codebook was developed using an iterative process. Three coders analyzed the data and synthesized data into thematic memos.
Participants reported challenges within the healthcare system, including barriers to receiving services, connection to or education on resources, challenges in and reasons for sharing their history of substance use with healthcare providers, provider reactions to this information, and the impact of providers' response to knowing about their substance use history. Participants described shame regarding their substance use but also a strong desire to ensure the health of their infants. This desire motivated them to share their history of substance use with healthcare providers. When participants perceived nonjudgmental and empathetic responses, they reported feeling pride and empowerment. Participants who reported judgmental responses from providers stated that it made them less likely to share and engage with other healthcare providers in the future.
The perspectives and experiences of people engaged in SUD treatment can inform the implementation of clinical guidelines for patient-centered care for pregnant and parenting people in perinatal healthcare settings. Learnings from this study addresses ongoing challenges to compassionate care during this critical window, leading to disengagement of patients. Support through connection of resources can be helpful for ongoing recovery. Recommendations are made to establish trust through transparency and non-judgmental care and to reinforce receipt of appropriate healthcare services.
美国的临床指南建议对患有物质使用障碍(SUD)的孕妇采取以患者为中心的医疗保健方法;然而,患有SUD的孕妇在寻求产前护理时经常描述自己遭受污名化和羞耻感。我们探讨了参与SUD治疗的孕妇和育儿者在围产期与医疗保健提供者接触的经历,以改进对以患者为中心的护理的指导。
我们采用一种改编的现象学方法,对从美国科罗拉多州的住院或门诊物质使用治疗中心招募的22名孕妇和育儿者进行了深入访谈。我们制定了一份访谈指南,以探讨参与者在怀孕、分娩和产后的经历。我们对访谈进行了录音、转录和验证,以便进行分析。通过迭代过程制定了一个编码手册。三名编码人员对数据进行了分析,并将数据综合成主题备忘录。
参与者报告了医疗保健系统中的挑战,包括获得服务的障碍、与资源的联系或对资源的了解、与医疗保健提供者分享其物质使用史的挑战及原因、提供者对该信息的反应,以及提供者对了解其物质使用史的反应的影响。参与者描述了对自己物质使用的羞耻感,但也有强烈的愿望确保婴儿的健康。这种愿望促使他们与医疗保健提供者分享自己的物质使用史。当参与者感受到无评判和共情的回应时,他们报告感到自豪和有力量。那些报告提供者有评判性回应的参与者表示,这使他们未来不太可能与其他医疗保健提供者分享信息并与之接触。
参与SUD治疗的人员的观点和经历可以为围产期医疗保健环境中为孕妇和育儿者提供以患者为中心的护理的临床指南的实施提供信息。本研究的经验教训解决了在这个关键时期提供 compassionate care(此处原文可能有误,推测为“富有同情心的护理”)时持续存在的挑战,这些挑战导致患者脱离治疗。通过资源连接提供支持有助于持续康复。建议通过透明度和无评判性护理建立信任,并加强获得适当的医疗保健服务。