Ishungisa Alexander M, Kilgallen Joseph A, Mabula Elisha, Brand Charlotte O, Urassa Mark, Lawson David W
National Institute for Medical Research, Mwanza, Tanzania.
Muhimbili University of Health and Allied Sciences, Dar es Salaam, Tanzania.
Evol Hum Sci. 2025 Feb 14;7:e10. doi: 10.1017/ehs.2025.4. eCollection 2025.
With the objective of informing theoretical accounts of social learning and gendered conflict, we explore the role of prestige in the formation of men's beliefs about gender in a semi-rural but fast urbanizing community in north-western Tanzania. Using focus groups and participant observation, we contrast the extent to which young men view elders and men from the neighbouring city as prestigious, and the beliefs they ascribe to each category. Elders were viewed as prestigious because of their age and position as preservers and teachers of societal norms. Their prestige was culturally mandated, as evidenced by customs bestowing respect. In contrast, only subcategories of city men were deemed prestigious dependent on individual achievement. Prestige was difficult to distinguish from dominance, as both elders and city men can exert penalties on those with differing views. Elders were viewed as mostly, but not always, unsupportive of women's empowerment, whereas city men were viewed as mostly, but not always, supportive of women's empowerment. We conclude that urbanization shifts the distribution of prestige, exposing individuals to novel sources of social influence. However, future studies should be wary not to oversimplify elders as upholders of patriarchal beliefs and city men as universally supportive of women's empowerment.
为了为社会学习和性别冲突的理论阐释提供信息,我们在坦桑尼亚西北部一个半乡村但快速城市化的社区中,探讨了声望在男性性别观念形成过程中的作用。通过焦点小组和参与观察,我们对比了年轻男性认为年长者和来自邻近城市的男性具有声望的程度,以及他们赋予每一类人的观念。年长者因其年龄以及作为社会规范的守护者和传授者的地位而被视为有声望。他们的声望是由文化赋予的,给予尊重的习俗就是证明。相比之下,只有城市男性的某些子类别因其个人成就而被认为有声望。声望与主导地位难以区分,因为年长者和城市男性都可以对持有不同观点的人施加惩罚。年长者大多(但并非总是)被认为不支持女性赋权,而城市男性大多(但并非总是)被认为支持女性赋权。我们得出结论,城市化改变了声望的分布,使个人接触到新的社会影响源。然而,未来的研究应注意,不要过于简单地将年长者视为父权制观念的支持者,将城市男性视为普遍支持女性赋权的群体。