Siu Judy Yuen-Man, Chan Engle Angela, Li Angus Siu-Cheong, Lee Yik Mun
Department of Applied Social Sciences, Faculty of Health and Social Sciences, The Hong Kong Polytechnic University, Hong Kong, People's Republic of China.
International Research Centre for the Advancement of Health Communication, The Hong Kong Polytechnic University, Hong Kong, People's Republic of China.
Health Expect. 2025 Apr;28(2):e70236. doi: 10.1111/hex.70236.
The COVID-19 pandemic has presented a major challenge to maintaining a stable blood supply. In Hong Kong, the percentage of eligible donors who donated blood dropped from 2.7% before the pandemic to 2.34% and 2% during the pandemic.
This study explored barriers to blood donation among nondonors and lapsed donors during the COVID-19 pandemic.
A critical medical anthropology framework and a qualitative descriptive design were used. In-depth semi-structured interviews were conducted individually between February and July 2021 in Hong Kong with 80 adults aged 19-65 years who were nondonors or who had previously donated blood but had lapsed from doing so.
The participants who did not donate blood during the pandemic reported multiple reasons that arose during the pandemic and before it. The decision to not donate is sometimes the outcome of a social process established before the pandemic. Although institutional infection control and quarantine policies were most relevant for nondonation during the pandemic, policy and structural factors intertwined and created new social and cultural ideals that demotivated participants from donating blood. The difficult relationship between mainland China and Hong Kong as well as participants' unpleasant experiences with personnel in donor centres served as underlying barriers before the pandemic.
The decision not to donate during the pandemic cannot be explained by pandemic factors alone. Although the participants' sense of being a 'good citizen' arising from the new social norms developed in the pandemic at the intermediate level (quarantine policy) and the macro-level social structure (collective responsibility) had affected their micro-level perceptions (blood donation as unnecessary and risky and healthcare personnel as dangerous), their experiences at different social levels preceded the pandemic had played an important embedding role in reinforcing their nondonation during the pandemic.
To enhance the motivation to donate blood among nondonors and lapsed donors, merely addressing the barriers arising from the pandemic is inadequate. Prepandemic factors should also be addressed.
The participants shared their experiences in the interviews. All participants had read and confirmed the content of their transcripts and referred more participants for this study.
新冠疫情对维持稳定的血液供应构成了重大挑战。在香港,符合献血条件的献血者比例从疫情前的2.7%降至疫情期间的2.34%和2%。
本研究探讨了新冠疫情期间非献血者和曾献血但已不再献血者的献血障碍。
采用批判性医学人类学框架和定性描述性设计。2021年2月至7月期间,在香港对80名年龄在19至65岁之间的成年人进行了单独的深入半结构化访谈,这些人要么是非献血者,要么曾献血但已不再献血。
在疫情期间未献血的参与者报告了疫情期间及之前出现的多种原因。不献血的决定有时是疫情前建立的社会过程的结果。虽然机构感染控制和检疫政策在疫情期间与不献血最为相关,但政策和结构因素相互交织,创造了新的社会和文化观念,使参与者失去了献血的动力。中国大陆与香港之间的紧张关系以及参与者在献血中心与工作人员不愉快的经历是疫情前的潜在障碍。
疫情期间不献血的决定不能仅用疫情因素来解释。尽管参与者在疫情期间在中间层面(检疫政策)和宏观层面社会结构(集体责任)形成的新社会规范中产生的“好公民”意识影响了他们的微观层面认知(认为献血不必要且有风险,医护人员危险),但他们在疫情前不同社会层面的经历在强化他们在疫情期间不献血方面起到了重要的嵌入作用。
为了提高非献血者和曾献血但已不再献血者的献血积极性,仅仅解决疫情带来的障碍是不够的。还应解决疫情前的因素。
参与者在访谈中分享了他们的经历。所有参与者都阅读并确认了他们访谈记录的内容,并为这项研究推荐了更多参与者。