Duffau Hugues, Moritz-Gasser Sylvie, Herbet Guillaume
1Department of Neurosurgery, Gui de Chauliac Hospital, Montpellier University Medical Center, Montpellier.
3Department of Medicine, University of Montpellier.
J Neurosurg. 2025 Apr 4:1-7. doi: 10.3171/2024.12.JNS242426.
In low-grade glioma (LGG), although awake surgery (AS) with intraoperative functional mapping helps to minimize neurological and cognitive deficits, its impact on artistic abilities has received less attention. This study is the first to assess the capacity of professional or semiprofessional artists to resume various art activities following AS for LGG.
Artists who underwent AS for an IDH-mutated WHO grade 2 glioma with connectome-based resection using cortico-subcortical electrostimulation were consecutively selected. Real-time, tailored multitasking was performed throughout the resection, but no additional tasks related to artistic abilities were introduced.
Nineteen patients were included, consisting of 15 professional artists (5 architects, 2 comedians, 2 musicians, 2 dancers, 1 sculptor, 1 plastic artist, 1 writer, and 1 art professor) and 4 semiprofessional artists-2 musicians (1 professor of chemistry, 1 informatician), 1 poet (theater administrator), and 1 painter (social worker). This consecutive cohort included 10 men (52.6%) and 9 women (47.4%) who underwent AS for LGG. Of the 19 patients, 16 were right-handed, the mean age was 36.8 ± 9.7 years, and the mean Karnofsky Performance Scale score was 94.7 ± 6.9. There were 11 left-sided and 8 right-sided tumors distributed across the 5 lobes (mean preoperative volume 52.8 ± 39.4 cm3). All patients were fully active before surgery, except for 1 architect with intractable epilepsy. Postoperatively, no permanent deficits were observed, except 1 case of voluntary induced hemianopia (5.3%). The mean Karnofsky Performance Scale score was 95.7 ± 5 at 3 months after surgery. All patients returned to their artistic practice at the semiprofessional or professional level, and none reported a subjective loss of creativity. The mean extent of resection was 91.2% ± 8.6% (mean residual tumoral volume 5 ± 5.8 cm3). There were 12 astrocytomas and 7 oligodendrogliomas. Only 1 patient received immediate adjuvant therapy. Five patients (26.3%) underwent subsequent AS. The mean follow-up duration was 7.6 ± 3.1 years since the initial AS. All patients except 3 (84.2%) were still alive at the last follow-up (1 died from an unrelated cause). There were no significant differences between professional and semiprofessional artists, except for a higher rate of reoperation in the latter subgroup (p = 0.037).
These original data show that AS with intraoperative continuous multitasking enabled semiprofessional and professional artists with LGG to resume their artistic work following surgery. This suggests that, although artistic creativity should be more systematically considered in surgical neuro-oncology, even for nonprofessional artists, there is nonetheless no need to introduce specific tests during surgery.
在低级别胶质瘤(LGG)中,尽管术中功能图谱引导下的清醒手术(AS)有助于将神经和认知功能缺损降至最低,但它对艺术能力的影响却较少受到关注。本研究首次评估了专业或半专业艺术家在接受LGG的AS手术后恢复各种艺术活动的能力。
连续选取接受基于皮质-皮质下电刺激的连接组切除术治疗IDH突变的世界卫生组织2级胶质瘤的艺术家。在整个切除过程中进行实时、量身定制的多任务处理,但未引入与艺术能力相关的额外任务。
纳入19例患者,包括15名专业艺术家(5名建筑师、2名喜剧演员、2名音乐家、2名舞者、1名雕塑家、1名造型艺术家、1名作家和1名艺术教授)和4名半专业艺术家——2名音乐家(1名化学教授、1名信息学家)、1名诗人(戏剧管理人员)和1名画家(社会工作者)。这个连续队列包括10名男性(52.6%)和9名女性(47.4%),他们接受了LGG的AS手术。19例患者中,16例为右利手,平均年龄为36.8±9.7岁,平均卡氏功能状态评分94.7±6.9。11例左侧肿瘤和8例右侧肿瘤分布在5个脑叶(术前平均体积52.8±39.4 cm³)。除1名患有难治性癫痫的建筑师外,所有患者术前均完全活跃。术后,除1例自愿性偏盲(5.3%)外,未观察到永久性缺损。术后3个月时平均卡氏功能状态评分为95.7±5。所有患者均恢复到半专业或专业水平的艺术实践,且均未报告主观创造力丧失。平均切除范围为91.2%±8.6%(平均残余肿瘤体积5±5.8 cm³)。有12例星形细胞瘤和7例少突胶质细胞瘤。仅1例患者接受了即刻辅助治疗。5例患者(26.3%)接受了后续的AS手术。自首次AS手术以来,平均随访时间为7.6±3.1年。除3例(84.2%)外,所有患者在最后一次随访时仍存活(1例死于无关原因)。除后一组的再次手术率较高外(p = 0.037),专业和半专业艺术家之间无显著差异。
这些原始数据表明,术中连续多任务处理的AS手术使患有LGG的半专业和专业艺术家术后能够恢复其艺术工作。这表明,尽管在手术神经肿瘤学中应更系统地考虑艺术创造力,但即使对于非专业艺术家,在手术期间也无需进行特定测试。